J Midwifery Womens Health. 2012 Nov-Dec;57(6):603-613. doi: 10.1111/j.1542-2011.2012.00248.x.
Title X, enacted in 1970, remains the only policy devoted solely to providing voluntary and confidential family planning and related preventative services to all those in need. Despite Title X's significant public health achievements, this policy continues to receive scrutiny and faces political, financial, and social challenges. This study explores key stakeholders' perceptions regarding the political contexts that have surrounded Title X over its historical maturation.
Six oral histories were conducted with key stakeholders in Florida using a semi structured interview guide developed from Title X's legislative history, McPhail's Feminist Policy Analysis Framework, and the literature. Oral histories were audio recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using open, axial, and selective coding in NVivo 8.
Participants identified and discussed the following political topics and controversies that they perceived have directly or indirectly affected Title X: abortion, adolescents, parental notification, school-based clinics, abstinence-only education, political administrations, and family planning methods.
Participants' recollections regarding the political contexts that have surrounded Title X over the past 4 decades provided a broad yet rich description of the barriers that exist with fulfilling this policy. Such opposition hinders Title X's ability to support women's right to reproductive health. Practitioners play a key role in advocating for family planning services and should understand the political issues hindering reproductive health policies and the need to translate family planning services as a basic human right.
1970 年颁布的《第十标题》仍然是唯一一项专门为所有有需要的人提供自愿和保密的计划生育及相关预防服务的政策。尽管《第十标题》取得了重大的公共卫生成就,但该政策仍在受到审查,并面临政治、财务和社会挑战。本研究探讨了关键利益相关者对《第十标题》在其历史发展过程中所面临的政治背景的看法。
在佛罗里达州,使用从《第十标题》立法历史、麦克菲尔的女性主义政策分析框架和文献中开发的半结构化访谈指南,对六位关键利益相关者进行了口头历史访谈。口头历史以音频形式记录、转录,并在 NVivo 8 中使用开放式、轴向式和选择性编码进行分析。
参与者确定并讨论了以下他们认为直接或间接影响《第十标题》的政治话题和争议:堕胎、青少年、父母通知、学校诊所、禁欲教育、政治行政和计划生育方法。
参与者对过去 40 年来围绕《第十标题》的政治背景的回忆,对履行该政策所存在的障碍进行了广泛而丰富的描述。这种反对阻碍了《第十标题》支持妇女生殖健康权利的能力。从业者在倡导计划生育服务方面发挥着关键作用,他们应该了解阻碍生殖健康政策的政治问题,以及将计划生育服务转化为基本人权的必要性。