Division of Movement Disorders, Great Lakes NeuroTechnologies Inc., 10055 Sweet Valley Drive, Cleveland, OH 44125, USA.
Gait Posture. 2013 May;38(1):109-14. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2012.10.025. Epub 2012 Dec 5.
Gait and balance disturbances in Parkinson's disease (PD) can be debilitating and may lead to increased fall risk. Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a treatment option once therapeutic benefits from medication are limited due to motor fluctuations and dyskinesia. Optimizing DBS parameters for gait and balance can be significantly more challenging than for other PD motor symptoms. Furthermore, inter-rater reliability of the standard clinical PD assessment scale, Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS), may introduce bias and washout important features of gait and balance that may respond differently to PD therapies. Study objectives were to evaluate clinician UPDRS gait and balance scoring inter-rater reliability, UPDRS sensitivity to different aspects of gait and balance, and how kinematic features extracted from motion sensor data respond to stimulation. Forty-two subjects diagnosed with PD were recruited with varying degrees of gait and balance impairment. All subjects had been prescribed dopaminergic medication, and 20 subjects had previously undergone DBS surgery. Subjects performed seven items of the gait and balance subset of the UPDRS while wearing motion sensors on the sternum and each heel and thigh. Inter-rater reliability varied by UPDRS item. Correlation coefficients between at least one kinematic feature and corresponding UPDRS scores were greater than 0.75 for six of the seven items. Kinematic features improved (p<0.05) from DBS-OFF to DBS-ON for three UPDRS items. Despite achieving high correlations with the UPDRS, evaluating individual kinematic features may help address inter-rater reliability issues and rater bias associated with focusing on different aspects of a motor task.
帕金森病(PD)患者的步态和平衡障碍可能会使人虚弱,并可能导致跌倒风险增加。当药物治疗的疗效因运动波动和运动障碍而受到限制时,深部脑刺激(DBS)是一种治疗选择。优化用于步态和平衡的 DBS 参数可能比其他 PD 运动症状更具挑战性。此外,标准临床 PD 评估量表,统一帕金森病评定量表(UPDRS)的评分者间可靠性可能会引入偏差,并消除可能对 PD 治疗有不同反应的步态和平衡的重要特征。研究目的是评估临床医生 UPDRS 步态和平衡评分的评分者间可靠性、UPDRS 对步态和平衡不同方面的敏感性,以及从运动传感器数据中提取的运动学特征如何对刺激做出反应。42 名被诊断为 PD 的患者被招募,他们的步态和平衡受损程度不同。所有患者均已服用多巴胺能药物,其中 20 名患者已接受 DBS 手术。受试者在胸骨和每个脚跟和大腿上佩戴运动传感器的情况下完成 UPDRS 步态和平衡子集中的七个项目。评分者间可靠性因 UPDRS 项目而异。七个项目中的六个项目的运动学特征与相应 UPDRS 评分之间的相关系数大于 0.75。对于三个 UPDRS 项目,从 DBS-OFF 到 DBS-ON,运动学特征有所改善(p<0.05)。尽管与 UPDRS 具有高度相关性,但评估单个运动学特征可能有助于解决与关注运动任务的不同方面相关的评分者间可靠性问题和评分者偏差。