Menninger Department of Psychiatry, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA.
Med Teach. 2013;35(2):e926-34. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2012.742494. Epub 2012 Dec 11.
The authors identify and describe strategies for success in writing for publication, including how to choose an educational research topic, define the question and choose the correct design, know the anatomy of a research paper, write each of the sections, optimize the writing before publication, choose a journal, and respond to editors and reviewers. The research question should be focused, modest, and achievable given the constraints of the setting, significant, and appropriately imbedded in the available literature. The choice of methods is determined by the nature of the educational research question and should conform to ethical standards. Specific strategies for writing include starting where it is easiest to do so, spontaneously and uncritically writing the first paragraphs through, minimizing external impediments to the work, and knowing how each section of a manuscript is routinely structured. All papers require a number of revisions with careful attention to accuracy and detail as well as to specific requirements of the target journal before submission. Authors should respond positively, not defensively, and in detail to all of the editor's and reviewers' suggestions for revision. Writing for success is therefore a disciplined and systematic process following prescribed steps, which, although hard work, is rewarding.
作者确定并描述了成功写作的策略,包括如何选择教育研究主题、定义问题并选择正确的设计、了解研究论文的结构、撰写各个部分、在发表前优化写作、选择期刊以及回复编辑和审稿人。研究问题应该集中、适度,并在给定的设置、重要性和适当的文献背景下具有可实现性。方法的选择取决于教育研究问题的性质,并应符合伦理标准。写作的具体策略包括从最容易的地方开始,自发地、不加批判地撰写最初的段落,尽量减少工作中的外部障碍,并了解手稿的每个部分通常是如何构建的。所有论文在提交前都需要经过多次修订,仔细注意准确性和细节,以及目标期刊的具体要求。作者应该对编辑和审稿人的所有修改建议做出积极、非防御性和详细的回应。因此,成功写作是一个有纪律和系统的过程,遵循规定的步骤,虽然艰苦,但却有回报。