Hawassa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
SAHARA J. 2011;8(1):13-8. doi: 10.1080/17290376.2011.9724979.
The study aimed to assess the association between male circumcision and HIV infection and STDs. The issue is controversial as various studies reported conflicting findings. A cross-sectional comparative study based on the secondary data of 18 Demographic Health Surveys (DHS), carried out in Sub-Saharan Africa starting from 2003, was conducted. From all surveys, information on 70 554 males aged 15 - 59 years was extracted. The association between male circumcision and HIV infection and STD symptoms (genital discharge or genital ulcer/sore) was assessed using binary logistic regression. Adjustment was made for sexual history and basic socio-demographic variables. The weighted prevalence of HIV among men 15 - 59 years was 3.1%. In the bivariate analysis uncircumcised status was significantly associated with risk of HIV, with odds ratio (OR) of 4.12 (95% CI: 3.85 - 4.42). The association was even more significant (4.95 (95% CI: 4.57-5.36)) after adjustment for number of lifetime sexual partners and socio-demographic variables. The risk associated with uncircumcised status is significantly lower among younger men aged 15 - 29 years than those in 30 - 59-year age category. About 5.5% of the study subjects reported either genital discharge or genital sore/ulcer in the preceding 12 months of the surveys. Circumcision status was not significantly associated with either of the symptoms, with adjusted OR of 1.07 (95% CI: 0.99 - 1.15). The study concludes that there is a strong association between uncircumcised status and HIV infection. Hence, male circumcision can be considered as a possible way of reducing the spread of HIV infection in areas where the practice is rare. A comprehensive study to assess the association between circumcision and different types of STDs is recommended.
本研究旨在评估男性割礼与 HIV 感染和性传播疾病(STD)之间的关联。由于各种研究报告的结果相互矛盾,这个问题存在争议。我们进行了一项基于撒哈拉以南非洲地区从 2003 年开始进行的 18 项人口健康调查(DHS)的二级数据的横断面比较研究。从所有调查中提取了 70554 名 15-59 岁男性的信息。使用二元逻辑回归评估了男性割礼与 HIV 感染和 STD 症状(生殖器分泌物或生殖器溃疡/疮)之间的关联。对性行为史和基本社会人口统计学变量进行了调整。15-59 岁男性中 HIV 的加权流行率为 3.1%。在单变量分析中,未割礼状态与 HIV 感染风险显著相关,比值比(OR)为 4.12(95%可信区间:3.85-4.42)。在调整了一生中性伴侣的数量和社会人口统计学变量后,这种关联更加显著(4.95(95%可信区间:4.57-5.36))。与未割礼状态相关的风险在 15-29 岁的年轻男性中明显低于 30-59 岁年龄组的男性。约 5.5%的研究对象在调查前 12 个月报告了生殖器分泌物或生殖器溃疡/疮。割礼状态与这两种症状均无显著关联,调整后的 OR 为 1.07(95%可信区间:0.99-1.15)。本研究得出结论,未割礼状态与 HIV 感染之间存在很强的关联。因此,在割礼做法罕见的地区,男性割礼可以被视为减少 HIV 感染传播的一种可能方式。建议进行一项综合研究,评估割礼与不同类型 STD 之间的关联。