Goza Franklin, Ryabov Igor
Department of Sociology and Center for Family and Demographic Research Bowling Green State University, Ohio.
Int Migr. 2012 Aug 1;50(4):157-185. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2435.2009.00590.x. Epub 2010 Jan 15.
This comparative study uses data collected in 1990 and 1991 to examine the remittance behavior of Brazilians who had recently arrived in Canada and the United States. These data permit an examination of remittance activity among immigrants relatively soon after their arrival in a pair of host destinations. Prior to contrasting the remittance activity of these newly arrived immigrants, we first document the high degree of similarity between the two groups at their time of arrival; a point that becomes important when contrasting their divergent outcomes. Next, this study contributes to the research literature on micro-level remittance patterns and behaviors by focusing on three policy relevant dependant variables. More specifically, multivariate analyses are undertaken to examine those individual-level factors that best determine: (1) who remits, (2) how much they remit, and (3) when funds are remitted for productive purposes. Because the data analyzed were collected with the same instrument, results are then contrasted for the two destinations.One major finding to emerge from this cross-national study was that even immigrants who are extremely similar on all socio-economic measures at time of arrival may soon manifest divergent outcomes due to their distinctive country of destination experiences. Consequently, although some common predictors were found in both locales, there were far fewer than expected. For example, family obligation variables were usually significant in the predicted directions for the United States data, while this was almost never the case for the Canadian data. Furthermore, some variables often assumed to predict remittance behavior were insignificant in both locations. This study concludes by considering possible explanations for these results, as well as discussing the need for additional theoretical work and data collection in the area of immigrant remittance activity.
这项比较研究使用了1990年和1991年收集的数据,以考察最近抵达加拿大和美国的巴西人的汇款行为。这些数据使得在移民抵达一对东道国目的地后不久就能对其汇款活动进行考察。在对比这些新抵达移民的汇款活动之前,我们首先记录了这两组人抵达时的高度相似性;这一点在对比他们不同的结果时变得很重要。接下来,本研究通过关注三个与政策相关的因变量,为关于微观层面汇款模式和行为的研究文献做出了贡献。更具体地说,进行了多变量分析,以考察那些最能决定以下方面的个人层面因素:(1)谁进行汇款,(2)他们汇出多少,以及(3)资金何时被汇出用于生产目的。由于所分析的数据是用相同的工具收集的,然后对两个目的地的结果进行了对比。这项跨国研究得出的一个主要发现是,即使是在抵达时所有社会经济指标都极其相似的移民,由于他们在不同目的地国家的独特经历,可能很快就会表现出不同的结果。因此,尽管在两个地区都发现了一些共同的预测因素,但数量比预期的要少得多。例如,家庭义务变量在美国数据的预测方向上通常是显著的,而在加拿大数据中几乎从未如此。此外,一些通常被认为可以预测汇款行为的变量在两个地区都不显著。本研究最后考虑了对这些结果的可能解释,并讨论了在移民汇款活动领域进行更多理论研究和数据收集的必要性。