Hutcheson Candice, Seale N Sue, McWhorter Alton, Kerins Carolyn, Wright John
Pediatr Dent. 2012 Nov-Dec;34(7):460-7.
Parents increasingly request esthetic restorations for their children's teeth. This split mouth, randomized controlled trial compared primary molars treated with white MTA pulpotomies and restored with either multi-surface composites (MSC) or stainless steel crowns (SSC).
Forty matched, contra-lateral pairs of molars received MTA pulpotomies and were randomly assigned to MSC or SSC restorations and evaluated clinically and radiographically at 6 and 12 months. Two calibrated, blinded examiners evaluated and scored radiographs.
Thirty-seven matched pairs were evaluated at 6 months, and 31 were available at 12 months. All teeth in both groups were radiographically and clinically successful at 6 and 12 months. Dentin bridge formation was noted in 20% of the primary molars by 12 months. Although not significant, the composite group exhibited fewer intact clinical margins than the SSC group. The vast majority (94%) of teeth restored with composite displayed gray discoloration at follow-up exams, which did not appear to affect the quality of the restoration and is believed to be associated with the white MTA.
The white MTA pulpotomies succeeded over 12 months regardless of the restoration; however, the teeth restored with composite were not as durable nor considered an esthetic alternative to the SSC.
家长越来越多地为孩子的牙齿寻求美观修复。这项双侧对照、随机对照试验比较了采用白色MTA进行活髓切断术并分别用多面复合树脂(MSC)或不锈钢冠(SSC)修复的乳磨牙。
40对匹配的对侧磨牙接受了MTA活髓切断术,并随机分配接受MSC或SSC修复,在6个月和12个月时进行临床和影像学评估。两名经过校准、不知情的检查者对X光片进行评估和评分。
37对匹配的磨牙在6个月时进行了评估,31对在12个月时仍可评估。两组所有牙齿在6个月和12个月时影像学和临床检查均成功。到12个月时,20%的乳磨牙出现牙本质桥形成。虽然差异不显著,但复合树脂组完整的临床边缘比SSC组少。在随访检查中,绝大多数(94%)用复合树脂修复的牙齿出现了灰色变色,这似乎并未影响修复质量,据信与白色MTA有关。
无论采用何种修复方式,白色MTA活髓切断术在12个月内均取得成功;然而,用复合树脂修复的牙齿耐久性较差,也不被认为是SSC的美观替代方案。