Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Medical Center, New York, NY 10003, USA.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2013 Jan;10(1):51-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2012.08.011.
The aim of this study was to assess the value and educational experience of instituting a weekly full-day educational conference format for radiology residents.
Two independent diagnostic radiology residency programs in a single urban health care network instituted a new teaching model in which residents from both programs participated in a weekly joint conference day. This format replaced independently held, but frequently teleconferenced, 1-hour daily conferences at both programs. Residents' and faculty members' perceptions of the educational experience were assessed using anonymous online surveys. Written board examination scores and number of resident dictations were compared before and after the change.
After 6 months, 30% and 53.3% of residents reported positive and neutral overall impressions, respectively. A survey return rate of 63.3% was achieved from 49 residents. Of 34 faculty members who responded, 50% reported increased preparation for conferences. The overall number of resident dictations modestly increased in the year after implementation of the format change, by 3.1%. There was no statistically significant change in the mean written board examination after the change in format compared with 3 years before the change.
Conference interruptions, cancellations, and tardiness were essentially eliminated with the new model. Individual conference quality was reported to have improved as the result of the more formal format and larger audience size. Residents maintained productivity and exposure to case volume despite the loss of a single clinical day. Although residents' perceptions of the new model were predominantly positive or neutral, downsides included fewer cases per resident in case conferences and a less intimate conference setting.
本研究旨在评估为放射科住院医师设立每周全天教育会议模式的价值和教育体验。
在一个单一的城市医疗网络中,两个独立的诊断放射学住院医师培训计划采用了一种新的教学模式,即两个计划的住院医师共同参加每周联合会议日。这种模式取代了两个计划分别举行但经常通过电话会议进行的 1 小时日常会议。使用匿名在线调查评估住院医师和教师对教育体验的看法。在更改前后比较了书面委员会考试成绩和住院医师听写的数量。
6 个月后,分别有 30%和 53.3%的住院医师报告了积极和中立的总体印象。从 49 名住院医师中获得了 63.3%的调查回复率。在做出回应的 34 名教师中,有 50%的人报告说他们为会议做了更多的准备。在实施格式更改后的一年中,住院医师听写的总数略有增加,增加了 3.1%。与更改前的 3 年相比,格式更改后书面委员会考试的平均成绩没有统计学意义上的变化。
新模型基本上消除了会议中断、取消和延迟。由于格式更加正式和听众规模更大,报告称个别会议质量有所提高。尽管失去了一个临床日,但住院医师仍保持了生产力和接触病例数量。尽管住院医师对新模式的看法主要是积极或中立的,但也存在一些缺点,包括病例会议中每个住院医师的病例减少,以及会议环境不那么亲密。