Department of Psychology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA.
J Neurosci. 2013 Jan 9;33(2):587-94. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1379-12.2013.
Threat evokes a variety of negative emotions such as fear, anger, and disgust. Whereas they elicit distinct and even opposite facial, sensory, and autonomic reflexes, threat-related emotions often converge in the actions they prompt (e.g., negative evaluation and avoidance). Here, we tested a unifying hypothesis that threat processing initially involves specialized encoding of individual subtypes to support discrete reflexive operations that later gives way to generalized elaborate analysis to facilitate convergent defensive behavior. Combining event-related potentials (ERPs) and a defensive context in human subjects, we compared temporal courses of perceptual analysis of two threat subtypes-fear and disgust. Indeed, fear enhanced and disgust suppressed early (115 ms) response in visual cortex, accentuating specialized sensory encoding of threat subtypes in accordance with the opposite behavioral and autonomic reflexes they typically elicit. By contrast, later ERP waveforms evoked by fear and disgust merged gradually over time (130-425 ms). Consistently, visual ERPs to anthropomorphic Greeble objects presented after fear versus disgust images also overlapped despite their clear departure from the neutral condition, paralleled by comparable exaggeration in Greeble imminence perception in the two threat (vs neutral) conditions. This later confluence of neural and behavioral response between fear and disgust thus highlights general threat categorization in high-level, downstream perception of threat. By delineating the temporal dynamics in perceiving individual threat emotions, our findings thus provide some of the first evidence to reconcile multidimensional and unidimensional aspects of information processing within the domain of threat, shedding new light on symptom heterogeneity across the anxiety disorder spectrum.
威胁会引发各种负面情绪,如恐惧、愤怒和厌恶。虽然它们会引发明显甚至相反的面部、感觉和自主反射,但与威胁相关的情绪通常会在它们引发的行为中融合(例如,负面评价和回避)。在这里,我们测试了一个统一的假设,即威胁处理最初涉及对个体亚型的专门编码,以支持离散的反射操作,然后让位于广义的精细分析,以促进收敛性防御行为。我们在人类受试者中结合事件相关电位(ERPs)和防御性上下文,比较了两种威胁亚型——恐惧和厌恶的感知分析的时间进程。事实上,恐惧增强了,厌恶抑制了视觉皮层中的早期(115 毫秒)反应,突出了威胁亚型的专门感觉编码,符合它们通常引发的相反行为和自主反射。相比之下,恐惧和厌恶诱发的后期 ERP 波形随着时间的推移逐渐融合(130-425 毫秒)。一致的是,尽管恐惧和厌恶条件下呈现的拟人化 Greeble 物体与中性条件明显不同,但在视觉 ERPs 中仍会重叠,并且在这两种威胁(与中性)条件下,对 Greeble 迫在眉睫的感知也会出现类似的夸大。因此,恐惧和厌恶之间的这种后期神经和行为反应的融合突出了高级、下游威胁感知中一般威胁分类。通过描绘个体威胁情绪感知的时间动态,我们的发现为整合威胁领域内信息处理的多维和单维方面提供了一些首批证据之一,为焦虑障碍谱中的症状异质性提供了新的见解。