Department of Community Medicine, Knowledge Utilization Research Center (KURC), Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2013 Apr;67(4):346-9. doi: 10.1136/jech-2012-201511. Epub 2013 Jan 15.
We performed this study to assess the trend of geographical disparities between rural areas located in the catchment areas of 41 medical universities in Iran from 1993 to 2008. We evaluated four indicators including rates for neonatal mortality (NMR), infant mortality (IMR), under-5 mortality (U5MR) and crude death (CDR).
We got about 656 university-year data points for each of the indicators (missing data <0.5%). The people under assessment were between 16.7 (in 1993) to 20.1 million (in 2008). We measured disparities through the calculation of index of disparities (IDisp) and assessed the trends using the Cuzick non-parametric test for trend.
Except for the increasing trend of CDR (Z=+2.83, p=0.005), the others had decreasing trends: NMR (Z=-3.23, p=0.001), IMR (Z=-3.84, p<0.001) and U5MR (Z=-3.84, p<0.001). The IDisp trends of IMR (Z=-2.2, p=0.027) and U5MR (Z=-2.84, p=0.005) were decreasing, while the IDisp trends for NMR (Z=+2.19, p=0.028) and CDR (Z=+2.39, p=0.017) were increasing.
The results show that at least for IMR and U5MR, in addition to improvement in average national levels, the geographical disparities have decreased. In the cases of NMR and CDR, inspite of the improvements in national levels, the trends of health disparities are not as good. We need to use strategies to provide more specialised care fairly in addition to primary healthcare to reduce disparities in CDR and NMR and influence them more.
本研究旨在评估 1993 年至 2008 年间伊朗 41 所医科大学所在流域农村地区之间的地理差异趋势。我们评估了包括新生儿死亡率(NMR)、婴儿死亡率(IMR)、5 岁以下儿童死亡率(U5MR)和粗死亡率(CDR)在内的四个指标。
我们获得了每个指标约 656 个大学-年的数据点(缺失数据<0.5%)。评估对象为 1993 年的 1670 万人至 2008 年的 2010 万人。我们通过计算差异指数(IDisp)来衡量差异,并使用 Cuzick 非参数趋势检验来评估趋势。
除 CDR(Z=+2.83,p=0.005)呈上升趋势外,其他指标均呈下降趋势:NMR(Z=-3.23,p=0.001)、IMR(Z=-3.84,p<0.001)和 U5MR(Z=-3.84,p<0.001)。IMR(Z=-2.2,p=0.027)和 U5MR(Z=-2.84,p=0.005)的 IDisp 趋势呈下降趋势,而 NMR(Z=+2.19,p=0.028)和 CDR(Z=+2.39,p=0.017)的 IDisp 趋势呈上升趋势。
结果表明,至少在 IMR 和 U5MR 方面,除了国家平均水平的提高外,地理差异也有所缩小。在 NMR 和 CDR 方面,尽管国家水平有所提高,但健康差异的趋势并不理想。我们需要采取策略,除了提供初级保健外,还要公平地提供更专业的护理,以减少 CDR 和 NMR 的差异,并对其产生更大的影响。