Persistence of donor-specific IL-2-secreting cells and cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors in human kidney transplant recipients evidenced by limiting dilution analysis.

The low reactivity to donor alloantigens reported in PBL from kidney transplant recipients might be related to clonal deletion and/or suppression of donor-specific alloreactive cells. To discriminate between these two hypotheses, we quantified the number of IL-2 secreting cells (IL-2-SC) and of cytotoxic precursors (CTLp) in the T cells from tolerant recipients when stimulated with either donor specific or nonrelated third-party LCL. To eliminate the irrelevant reactivity, we used as responding cells high-density T cells that had been depleted of such reactivity by 4 days preculture with autologous lymphoblastoid cell line in the presence of bromodeoxyuridine. Thus, frequencies of IL-2-SC and CTLp specifically directed at alloantigens could be measured. In 11 recipients, there was no strong decrease in the frequency of donor-reactive T cells when compared to the frequency of those directed at a third-party lymphoblastoid cell line, either for IL-2-SC (tested in 11 patients) or for CTLp (tested in 6 patients). In three cases of seven, a suppression was observed only when T cells were stimulated by donor cells. These data suggest that donor-reactive cells are still present in PBL of kidney-transplant recipients tested from 6 mo to 4 y posttransplantation. Moreover, suppression of donor-specific cells can be demonstrated in peripheral T cells of some recipients, which may account in part for the absence of rejection.