Departments of Otorhinolaryngology, Sainte-Justine University Hospital, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2013 Jan;139(1):54-8. doi: 10.1001/jamaoto.2013.1063.
OBJECTIVES To evaluate whether a low rate of exposure to sinonasal computed tomographic (CT) scans can be achieved when strict criteria are applied for their use in children with cystic fibrosis (CF) and to emphasize the importance of limiting radiation exposure in the context of the current longer life expectancy in this group of patients. DESIGN Retrospective chart review. SETTING Tertiary care children's hospital. PATIENTS The study included 277 children who were regularly followed up in the CF clinic in the last 11 years (mean duration of follow up, 7.87 years), 33 of whom underwent sinonasal CT. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Indications used for scanning, health professional (ear, nose, and throat specialist or pulmonologist) ordering the test, eventual modifications of ongoing treatment according to CT results, and time lapse between CT scanning and surgery. RESULTS Of 277 children with CF, 33 (12%) underwent a total of 39 sinonasal CT scans during the follow-up period (0.018 scans per patient per year of follow-up). Twenty-nine of the CT scans (74% of all cases, 90% of CT scans ordered by the ear, nose, and throat surgeon) were performed in the preoperative context and demonstrated the extent of the polypoid disease whenever present (26 cases [90%]) and the cause of nasal obstruction (20 cases [69%]). The mean period between the scanning and the surgery was 57 days (range, 0.10-173 days). Computed tomographic scans that were not meant for preoperative planning were performed in 10 cases (26%). The indications were disease evaluation (10%), ruling out a mucocele (5%); pre-lung transplantation status (5%), ruling out an intraorbital complication (3%); and headache investigation (3%). The results of the scans did not modify the management of the disease in those patients. CONCLUSIONS With the use of stringent criteria, it is possible to achieve a low rate of exposure to sinonasal CT scans in the population of children with CF. The main indication should be the preoperative planning regarding anatomy, extent of disease, and sites of nasal obstruction. The use of CT scans for disease evaluation does not seem to appreciably modify the treatment course and could be avoided.
评估在严格标准下,囊性纤维化 (CF) 患儿接受鼻窦计算机断层扫描 (CT) 的比例是否可以降低,并强调在这组患者预期寿命延长的背景下限制辐射暴露的重要性。
回顾性图表审查。
三级儿童保健医院。
本研究纳入了过去 11 年在 CF 门诊接受定期随访的 277 名儿童(平均随访时间为 7.87 年),其中 33 名儿童接受了鼻窦 CT 检查。
扫描的适应证、开检查单的卫生专业人员(耳鼻喉科专家或肺科专家)、根据 CT 结果对正在进行的治疗的调整以及 CT 扫描和手术之间的时间间隔。
在 277 名 CF 患儿中,33 名(12%)患儿在随访期间共进行了 39 次鼻窦 CT 扫描(每位患者每年 0.018 次)。29 次 CT 扫描(所有病例的 74%,耳鼻喉科医生开的 CT 扫描的 90%)在术前进行,无论是否存在息肉样病变,均显示其范围(26 例[90%])和鼻阻塞的原因(20 例[69%])。扫描与手术之间的平均时间间隔为 57 天(范围为 0.10-173 天)。另有 10 次(26%)非术前计划的 CT 扫描的适应证为疾病评估(10%)、排除黏液囊肿(5%)、肺移植前评估(5%)、排除眶内并发症(3%)和头痛调查(3%)。这些患者的扫描结果并未改变疾病的治疗。
严格遵循标准,可降低 CF 患儿接受鼻窦 CT 扫描的比例。主要适应证应为术前评估解剖结构、疾病范围和鼻阻塞部位。出于疾病评估目的而进行 CT 扫描似乎不会明显改变治疗方案,可以避免。