Environmental and occupational medicine and consultant respiratory physician, Institute of Medical Sciences, UK.
Br J Gen Pract. 2013 Jan;63(606):e47-54. doi: 10.3399/bjgp13X660779.
Most individuals with lung cancer have symptoms for several months before presenting to their GP. Earlier consulting may improve survival.
To evaluate whether a theory-based primary care intervention increased timely consulting of individuals with symptoms of lung cancer.
Open randomised controlled trial comparing intervention with usual care in two general practices in north-east Scotland.
Smokers and ex-smokers aged ≥55 years were randomised to receive a behavioural intervention or usual care. The intervention comprised a single nurse consultation at participants' general practice and a self-help manual. The main outcomes were consultations within target times for individuals with new chest symptoms (≤3 days haemoptysis, ≤3 weeks other symptoms) in the year after the intervention commenced, and intentions about consulting with chest symptoms at 1 and 6 months.
Two hundred and twelve participants were randomised and 206 completed the trial. The consultation rate for new chest symptoms in the intervention group was 1.19 (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.92 to 1.53; P = 0.18) times higher than in the usual-care group and the proportion of consultations within the target time was 1.11 (95% CI = 0.41 to 3.03; P = 0.83) times higher. One month after the intervention commenced, the intervention group reported intending to consult with chest symptoms 31 days (95% CI = 7 to 54; P = 0.012) earlier than the usual care group, and at 6 months this was 25 days (95% CI = 1.5 to 48; P = 0.037) earlier.
Behavioural intervention in primary care shortened the time individuals at high risk of lung disease intended to take before consulting with new chest symptoms (the secondary outcome of the study), but increases in consultation rates and the proportions of consultations within target times were not statistically significant.
大多数肺癌患者在就诊于全科医生之前有几个月的症状。早期咨询可能会提高生存率。
评估基于理论的初级保健干预是否会增加有肺癌症状的个体的及时咨询。
在苏格兰东北部的两家全科诊所进行了一项比较干预组与常规护理组的开放性随机对照试验。
将年龄≥55 岁的吸烟者和前吸烟者随机分配接受行为干预或常规护理。干预措施包括在参与者的全科诊所进行一次护士咨询和一本自我帮助手册。主要结果是在干预开始后的一年内,新出现胸部症状(≤3 天咯血,≤3 周其他症状)的个体在目标时间内进行咨询的情况,以及在 1 个月和 6 个月时对胸部症状进行咨询的意向。
共有 212 名参与者被随机分配,206 名完成了试验。干预组新出现胸部症状的咨询率是常规护理组的 1.19 倍(95%置信区间[CI] = 0.92 至 1.53;P = 0.18),而在目标时间内进行咨询的比例则是常规护理组的 1.11 倍(95%CI = 0.41 至 3.03;P = 0.83)。在干预开始后的一个月,干预组报告打算在出现胸部症状后 31 天(95%CI = 7 至 54;P = 0.012)进行咨询,而在 6 个月时则提前了 25 天(95%CI = 1.5 至 48;P = 0.037)。
初级保健中的行为干预缩短了患有肺部疾病高风险的个体在出现新的胸部症状之前打算咨询的时间(该研究的次要结果),但咨询率和在目标时间内进行咨询的比例的增加没有统计学意义。