Joint Doctoral Program in Public Health, San Diego State University & University of California, San Diego, PO Box 3900, Fifth Avenue, Suite 310, San Diego, CA 92103, USA.
J Sch Health. 2013 Mar;83(3):150-6. doi: 10.1111/josh.12010.
School policies can change practices on a relatively permanent basis. This study investigated adoption and implementation of state-level policies specifying minutes (or percent) of physical activity in physical education (PE) or during school.
Policies were identified from existing databases and rated as having weak, moderate, or strong wording. Interviews with state-level PE coordinators were conducted to investigate the level of implementation, monitoring, and enforcement of the identified policies.
Sixteen states had a policy that met inclusion criteria (19 policies total); 11 states had a policy addressing minutes of physical activity during school, 2 had a policy addressing percent of PE time to be spent in physical activity, and 3 had policies addressing both. None of the 19 policies were rated as having strong wording and 5 were rated as having moderate wording. The range in minutes of physical activity per week addressed in the policies was 60 to 300. Four of the 5 (elementary) and 5 of 5 (middle) policies addressing percent of PE spent physically active specified 50%. The only monitoring efforts reported consisted of schools self-reporting progress to the state.
More states need to adopt school physical activity policies and policy language needs to be more specific to prevent potential loopholes. Monitoring and evaluation strategies, beyond school self-report, are likely needed for these policies to lead to increases in physical activity.
学校政策可以相对永久地改变实践。本研究调查了州级政策的采用和实施情况,这些政策规定了体育教育(PE)或在校期间的体育活动时间(或百分比)。
从现有数据库中确定政策,并根据措辞的强弱进行评分。对州级体育协调员进行访谈,以调查所确定政策的实施、监测和执行情况。
16 个州有符合纳入标准的政策(共 19 项政策);11 个州有关于在校期间体育活动时间的政策,2 个州有关于体育课中体育活动时间百分比的政策,3 个州有同时涉及这两方面的政策。19 项政策中没有一项被评为措辞强硬,5 项被评为措辞中等。政策中规定的每周体育活动时间范围为 60 至 300 分钟。在规定体育课中体育活动百分比的 5 项(小学)和 5 项(中学)政策中,有 4 项和 5 项分别规定了 50%。报告的唯一监测工作是学校向州报告进展情况。
更多的州需要通过学校体育活动政策,政策措辞需要更加具体,以防止潜在的漏洞。这些政策需要监测和评估策略,而不仅仅是学校自我报告,以增加体育活动。