Uppsala University, Department of Ecology and Genetics, Limnology, Uppsala, Sweden.
PLoS One. 2013;8(1):e53516. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0053516. Epub 2013 Jan 22.
The recognition and discrimination of phytoplankton species is one of the foundations of freshwater biodiversity research and environmental monitoring. This step is frequently a bottleneck in the analytical chain from sampling to data analysis and subsequent environmental status evaluation. Here we present phytoplankton diversity data from 49 lakes including three seasonal surveys assessed by next generation sequencing (NGS) of 16S ribosomal RNA chloroplast and cyanobacterial gene amplicons and also compare part of these datasets with identification based on morphology. Direct comparison of NGS to microscopic data from three time-series showed that NGS was able to capture the seasonality in phytoplankton succession as observed by microscopy. Still, the PCR-based approach was only semi-quantitative, and detailed NGS and microscopy taxa lists had only low taxonomic correspondence. This is probably due to, both, methodological constraints and current discrepancies in taxonomic frameworks. Discrepancies included Euglenophyta and Heterokonta that were scarce in the NGS but frequently detected by microscopy and Cyanobacteria that were in general more abundant and classified with high resolution by NGS. A deep-branching taxonomically unclassified cluster was frequently detected by NGS but could not be linked to any group identified by microscopy. NGS derived phytoplankton composition differed significantly among lakes with different trophic status, showing that our approach can resolve phytoplankton communities at a level relevant for ecosystem management. The high reproducibility and potential for standardization and parallelization makes our NGS approach an excellent candidate for simultaneous monitoring of prokaryotic and eukaryotic phytoplankton in inland waters.
浮游植物物种的识别和区分是淡水生物多样性研究和环境监测的基础之一。这一步通常是从采样到数据分析以及随后的环境状况评估的分析链中的一个瓶颈。在这里,我们展示了来自 49 个湖泊的浮游植物多样性数据,其中包括三个季节调查,这些调查是通过 16S 核糖体 RNA 叶绿体和蓝细菌基因扩增子的下一代测序 (NGS) 进行评估的,并且还将部分这些数据集与基于形态的识别进行了比较。NGS 与三个时间序列的显微镜数据的直接比较表明,NGS 能够捕捉到浮游植物演替的季节性,就像显微镜观察到的那样。尽管如此,基于 PCR 的方法只是半定量的,并且详细的 NGS 和显微镜分类群列表只有低的分类对应关系。这可能是由于方法学限制和当前分类框架中的差异造成的。差异包括 Euglenophyta 和 Heterokonta,它们在 NGS 中很少,但在显微镜下经常检测到,以及 Cyanobacteria,它们通常更丰富,并且通过 NGS 以高分辨率分类。一个深分支的分类上未分类的聚类经常被 NGS 检测到,但无法与显微镜识别的任何组联系起来。具有不同营养状态的湖泊之间的 NGS 衍生浮游植物组成有显著差异,表明我们的方法可以解决与生态系统管理相关的浮游植物群落水平。高重现性和标准化和并行化的潜力使我们的 NGS 方法成为内陆水域中同时监测原核和真核浮游植物的优秀候选方法。