Forensic Psychiatry Division, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Psychiatr Serv. 2013 May 1;64(5):437-44. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201200170.
OBJECTIVE This study compared rates of arrest and incarceration, psychiatric hospitalization, homelessness, and discharge from assertive community treatment (ACT) programs for forensic and nonforensic clients in New York State and explored associated risk factors. METHODS Data were extracted from the New York State Office of Mental Health's Web-based outcome reporting system. ACT clients admitted between July 1, 2003, and June 30, 2007 (N=4,756), were divided into three groups by their forensic status at enrollment: recent (involvement in the past six months), remote (forensic involvement was more than six months prior), and no history. Client characteristics as of ACT enrollment and outcomes at one, two, and three years were compared over time. RESULTS Clients with forensic histories had a significantly higher ongoing risk of arrest or incarceration, and those with recent criminal justice involvement had a higher risk of homelessness and early discharge from ACT. Psychiatric hospitalization rates did not differ significantly across groups. Rates of all adverse outcomes were highest in the first year for all ACT clients, especially for those with a recent forensic history, and rates of psychiatric hospitalization, homelessness, and discharge declined over time for all clients. For all ACT clients, homelessness and problematic substance abuse at enrollment were significant risk factors for arrest or incarceration and for homelessness on three-year follow-up. CONCLUSIONS Clients with recent forensic histories were vulnerable to an array of adverse outcomes, particularly during their first year of ACT. This finding highlights the need for additional strategies to improve forensic and other outcomes for this high-risk population.
本研究比较了纽约州有犯罪记录和无犯罪记录的法医和非法医客户在被捕和监禁、精神科住院、无家可归以及从坚定社区治疗(ACT)项目中出院的比率,并探讨了相关的风险因素。
从纽约州心理健康办公室的基于网络的结果报告系统中提取数据。2003 年 7 月 1 日至 2007 年 6 月 30 日期间,根据入组时的法医状况,将 ACT 客户分为三组:近期(过去六个月内参与)、远程(法医参与时间超过六个月)和无历史。比较了客户特征在 ACT 入组时以及一年、两年和三年的结果。
有犯罪记录的客户持续被捕或监禁的风险明显更高,而近期有刑事司法参与的客户无家可归和提前从 ACT 出院的风险更高。精神病住院率在各组之间无显著差异。所有不良后果的发生率在所有 ACT 客户的第一年最高,尤其是那些有近期法医记录的客户,所有客户的精神病住院率、无家可归率和出院率随着时间的推移而下降。对于所有 ACT 客户,入组时的无家可归和有问题的物质滥用是被捕或监禁以及三年随访时无家可归的显著风险因素。
近期有犯罪记录的客户易受到一系列不良后果的影响,尤其是在 ACT 的第一年。这一发现强调了需要制定额外的策略,以改善这一高风险人群的法医和其他结果。