Morgenlander J C, Wilkins R H
Division of Neurology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina.
J Neurosurg. 1990 Jun;72(6):866-71. doi: 10.3171/jns.1990.72.6.0866.
Cluster headache is ordinarily managed medically, but may become refractory to such medical management. In this setting, surgical treatment has occasionally been performed, based on evidence that pertinent pain pathways and parasympathetic pathways may be interrupted at the main sensory root of the trigeminal nerve and at the nervus intermedius. Between 1976 and 1987, 13 patients underwent surgery for treatment of cluster headache that was refractory to medical therapy (15 procedures). Partial sectioning of the main sensory root and sectioning of the nervus intermedius were performed in nine patients; only partial sectioning of the main sensory root in one; only sectioning of the nervus intermedius in one; and nervus intermedius sectioning plus microvascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve in two. The average postoperative period for the 13 patients was 37 months (range 2 to 135 months). All patients had return of their headaches postoperatively except for one patient who obtained relief after a repeat procedure. Headache began to return between 2 days and 2 years postoperatively. Three patients are currently free of headache, including both patients who had nervus intermedius sectioning plus microvascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve. Together with recurrence of headache, cluster-associated autonomic disturbances recurred after 14 of the 15 operations but are currently absent in the three headache-free patients. Partial sectioning of the main sensory root and sectioning of the nervus intermedius, as performed in these patients, seem to have limited value in the treatment of cluster headache.
丛集性头痛通常采用药物治疗,但可能对这种药物治疗产生耐药性。在这种情况下,基于相关疼痛通路和副交感神经通路可能在三叉神经主感觉根和中间神经处被阻断的证据,偶尔会进行手术治疗。1976年至1987年间,13例患者因药物治疗无效的丛集性头痛接受了手术(共15次手术)。9例患者进行了三叉神经主感觉根部分切断术和中间神经切断术;1例仅进行了三叉神经主感觉根部分切断术;1例仅进行了中间神经切断术;2例进行了中间神经切断术加三叉神经微血管减压术。13例患者的平均术后时间为37个月(范围为2至135个月)。除1例患者在重复手术后缓解外,所有患者术后头痛均复发。头痛在术后2天至2年之间开始复发。目前有3例患者无头痛,包括2例进行了中间神经切断术加三叉神经微血管减压术的患者。与头痛复发一起,15例手术中有14例术后丛集性相关自主神经紊乱复发,但目前3例无头痛患者中不存在这种情况。这些患者所进行的三叉神经主感觉根部分切断术和中间神经切断术在丛集性头痛治疗中的价值似乎有限。