Harvard School of Public Health, Harvard University, Boston, MA, USA.
World J Surg. 2013 Apr;37(4):721-9. doi: 10.1007/s00268-013-1903-2.
There is a significant burden of disease in low-income countries that can benefit from surgical intervention. The goal of this survey was to evaluate the current ability of the Liberian health care system to provide safe surgical care and to identify unmet needs in regard to trained personnel, equipment, infrastructure, and outcomes measurement.
A comprehensive survey tool was developed to assess physical infrastructure of operative facilities, education and training for surgical and anesthesia providers, equipment and medications, and the capacity of the surgical system to collect and evaluate surgical outcomes at district-level hospitals in Africa. This tool was implemented in a sampling of 11 county hospitals in Liberia (January 2011). Data were obtained from the Ministry of Health and by direct government-affiliated hospital site visits.
The total catchment area of the 11 hospitals surveyed was 2,313,429--equivalent to roughly 67 % of the population of Liberia (3,476,608). There were 13 major operating rooms and 34 (1.5 per 100,000 population) physicians delivering surgical, obstetric, or anesthesia care including 2 (0.1 per 100,000 population) who had completed formal postgraduate training programs in these specialty areas. The total number of surgical cases for 2010 was 7,654, with approximately 43 % of them being elective procedures. Among the facilities that tracked outcomes in 2010, a total of 11 intraoperative deaths (145 per 100,000 operative cases) were recorded for 2009. The 30-day postoperative mortality at hospitals providing data was 44 (1,359 per 100,000 operative cases). Metrics were also used to evaluate surgical output, safety of anesthesia, and the burden of obstetric disease.
A significant volume of surgical care is being delivered at county hospitals throughout Liberia. The density and quality of appropriately trained personnel and infrastructure remain critically low. There is strong evidence for continued development of emergency and essential surgical services, as well as improved surgical outcomes tracking, at county hospitals in Liberia. These results serve to inform the international community and donors of the ongoing global surgical and anesthesia crisis.
在低收入国家,有大量的疾病负担可以通过手术干预来改善。本调查的目的是评估利比里亚卫生保健系统提供安全手术护理的现有能力,并确定在培训人员、设备、基础设施和结果测量方面的未满足需求。
开发了一个综合调查工具,以评估手术设施的物理基础设施、外科和麻醉提供者的教育和培训、设备和药物,以及收集和评估非洲区医院手术结果的外科系统能力。该工具在利比里亚的 11 家县医院进行了抽样调查(2011 年 1 月)。数据来自卫生部和政府附属医院的直接现场访问。
接受调查的 11 家医院的总服务面积为 2313429 人,相当于利比里亚人口的 67%(3476608 人)。有 13 个主要手术室和 34 名(每 10 万人中有 1.5 名)提供外科、产科或麻醉护理的医生,其中包括 2 名(每 10 万人中有 0.1 名)在这些专业领域完成了正规研究生培训计划。2010 年的手术病例总数为 7654 例,其中约 43%为择期手术。在 2010 年跟踪结果的设施中,记录了 2009 年共 11 例术中死亡(每 10 万例手术中有 145 例)。提供数据的医院 30 天术后死亡率为 44 例(每 10 万例手术中有 1359 例)。还使用指标来评估手术输出、麻醉安全性和产科疾病负担。
在利比里亚的县医院,大量的手术护理正在提供。适当培训人员和基础设施的密度和质量仍然非常低。有强有力的证据表明,需要在利比里亚的县医院继续发展紧急和基本的外科服务,并改进手术结果的跟踪。这些结果有助于向国际社会和捐助者通报全球外科和麻醉危机的现状。