Notzon F C
National Center for Health Statistics, US Department of Health and Human Services, Hyattsville, Md 20782.
JAMA. 1990 Jun 27;263(24):3286-91.
This study investigated current levels and trends between 1975 and 1986 in the rates of cesarean section in 21 countries and of operative vaginal delivery in 14 countries. Sharp differences in national obstetric practice were found, with cesarean rates ranging from a high of 32 (Brazil) to 7 (Czechoslovakia) per 100 hospital deliveries, and operative vaginal rates from 16 (Canada) to 2 (Czechoslovakia) per 100 hospital deliveries. For most countries, rates of cesarean section have risen as operative vaginal rates have fallen, but some important exceptions exist. A comparison of cesarean section rates for two complications of labor and delivery that can be objectively diagnosed, multiple births and breech delivery, demonstrates that cesarean section rates for these complications rose sharply in almost every country from 1980 to 1985. A comparison of 1985 national rates of intervention and measures of birth outcome found no significant relationship between the two. While such ecological comparisons are imperfect at best, this does indicate that low levels of early infant mortality can be achieved in some populations despite a low rate of cesarean deliveries.
本研究调查了1975年至1986年间21个国家的剖宫产率以及14个国家的阴道助产率的当前水平和变化趋势。研究发现各国产科实践存在显著差异,剖宫产率每100例住院分娩中从高的32例(巴西)到7例(捷克斯洛伐克)不等,阴道助产率每100例住院分娩中从16例(加拿大)到2例(捷克斯洛伐克)不等。对于大多数国家来说,剖宫产率上升而阴道助产率下降,但也存在一些重要的例外情况。对两种可客观诊断的分娩并发症(多胎妊娠和臀位分娩)的剖宫产率进行比较表明,从1980年到1985年,这些并发症的剖宫产率在几乎每个国家都急剧上升。对1985年各国的干预率和出生结局指标进行比较发现,两者之间没有显著关系。尽管这种生态学比较充其量是不完美的,但这确实表明,在一些人群中,尽管剖宫产率较低,仍可实现较低的早期婴儿死亡率。