Kim Peter K, Huh Heesun C, Cohen Hillel W, Feinberg Elyssa J, Ahmad Salman, Coyle Christina, Teperman Sheldon, Boothe Hugh
1 Department of Surgery, Albert Einstein College of Medicine and Jacobi Medical Center , Bronx, New York.
Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2013 Dec;14(6):532-9. doi: 10.1089/sur.2012.158. Epub 2013 Apr 5.
Clostridium difficile colitis is associated with increased age, antibiotic usage, and hospitalization. Severe C. difficile colitis refractory to medical therapy may require surgical intervention including subtotal colectomy. We initiated an adjuvant intracolonic vancomycin (ICV) enema protocol for inpatients with severe C. difficile colitis and compared the response to this therapy in patients from the community and nursing homes.
A single-hospital, retrospective chart review was done on 47 consecutive patients with C. difficile colitis treated with ICV (1 g/500 mL normal saline q6h) from January 2007 through October 2009. The proportions of patients with the outcomes of response to the ICV protocol, need for subtotal colectomy, and death were described. Associations of patient characteristics with these outcomes were examined with bivariate tests and multivariable logistic models with adjustment for age, hypoalbuminemia, acidosis, and nursing-home status.
Thirty-three of 47 patients (70%) with severe C. difficile colitis responded to adjunct ICV with complete resolution without surgery. Incomplete responders who had surgery were more likely to survive than those patients who did not undergo subtotal colectomy (p<0.01). Seven of nine patients who underwent surgery survived >90 d, and overall, 37 of 47 patients (79%) survived after ICV therapy. Nursing-home residence, acidosis, and hypoalbuminemia were significantly associated with the non-resolution of colitis in bivariate analyses (all p<0.01), whereas nursing-home residence and hypoalbuminemia showed non-significant trends toward association with death (p=0.07 and p=0.06, respectively). Multivariate logistic-regression models showed significant associations of acidosis with an incomplete response to ICV (p=0.02), of older age with death (p=0.04), and of hypoalbuminemia with both an incomplete response to ICV and death (both p=0.04). No complications were attributable to ICV.
Complete resolution without surgery was achieved in 70% in this series of patients with severe C. difficile colitis who received adjunct ICV therapy. A clinical trial will be needed to determine whether ICV as compared with standard therapy alone can reduce the need for surgery with non-inferior or superior outcomes.
艰难梭菌性结肠炎与年龄增长、抗生素使用及住院治疗相关。对药物治疗难治的严重艰难梭菌性结肠炎可能需要手术干预,包括次全结肠切除术。我们为患有严重艰难梭菌性结肠炎的住院患者启动了辅助性结肠内万古霉素(ICV)灌肠方案,并比较了社区患者和养老院患者对该治疗的反应。
对2007年1月至2009年10月期间连续47例接受ICV(1克/500毫升生理盐水,每6小时一次)治疗的艰难梭菌性结肠炎患者进行了单中心回顾性病历审查。描述了对ICV方案有反应、需要进行次全结肠切除术和死亡等结局的患者比例。通过双变量检验和多变量逻辑模型,对患者特征与这些结局的关联进行了分析,并对年龄、低白蛋白血症、酸中毒和养老院状态进行了校正。
47例严重艰难梭菌性结肠炎患者中有33例(70%)对辅助性ICV治疗有反应,结肠炎完全缓解且无需手术。接受手术的不完全反应者比未接受次全结肠切除术的患者更有可能存活(p<0.01)。9例接受手术的患者中有7例存活超过90天,总体而言,47例患者中有37例(79%)在ICV治疗后存活。在双变量分析中,养老院居住、酸中毒和低白蛋白血症与结肠炎未缓解显著相关(均p<0.01),而养老院居住和低白蛋白血症与死亡的关联呈非显著趋势(分别为p=0.07和p=0.06)。多变量逻辑回归模型显示,酸中毒与对ICV治疗反应不完全显著相关(p=0.02),高龄与死亡显著相关(p=0.04),低白蛋白血症与对ICV治疗反应不完全及死亡均显著相关(均p=0.04)。未发现与ICV相关的并发症。
在这组接受辅助性ICV治疗的严重艰难梭菌性结肠炎患者中,70%的患者无需手术即实现了完全缓解。需要进行一项临床试验,以确定与单独的标准治疗相比,ICV是否能在不劣于或优于标准治疗的情况下减少手术需求。