Wittouck Ciska, Dekkers Anne, De Ruyver Brice, Vanderplasschen Wouter, Vander Laenen Freya
Department of Penal Law and Criminology, Institute for International Research on Criminal Policy (IRCP), Ghent University, 9000 Ghent, Belgium.
ScientificWorldJournal. 2013;2013:493679. doi: 10.1155/2013/493679. Epub 2013 Mar 21.
Earlier reviews regarding the effectiveness of Drug Treatment Courts (DTCs) reported a reduction in reoffending and substance use. Although substance users suffer from other difficulties than drug use and judicial issues, none of these reviews focused on outcomes or effects of DTCs on drug-related life domains, such as social relationships, employment, or health. Therefor, the present paper aims to review the impact of adult DTCs on substance use and drug-related life domains.
Primary studies were systematically searched in Web of Knowledge. Observational and controlled evaluation studies of adult DTCs were considered eligible if substance use and/or drug-related life domains were measured.
Moderately positive results were found with respect to within-program substance use. Few studies used drug-related life domains as an outcome measure and most of them yielded no effects. Employment and family relations ameliorated when specific interventions were used.
DTCs yield beneficial outcomes and effects regarding within-program substance use. However, evidence regarding the impact of DTCs on post-program drug and alcohol use and on other drug-related life domains is scarce. These life domains and thus QoL possibly can be improved by DTCs if specifically targeted. Future research is warranted.
早期关于毒品治疗法庭(DTCs)有效性的综述报告称,再犯率和药物使用有所降低。尽管吸毒者除了药物使用和司法问题外还面临其他困难,但这些综述均未关注DTCs对与毒品相关的生活领域(如社会关系、就业或健康)的结果或影响。因此,本文旨在综述成人DTCs对药物使用和与毒品相关的生活领域的影响。
在《科学引文索引》中系统检索了原始研究。如果对药物使用和/或与毒品相关的生活领域进行了测量,则成人DTCs的观察性和对照评估研究被视为符合条件。
在项目内药物使用方面发现了适度的积极结果。很少有研究将与毒品相关的生活领域作为结果指标,而且大多数研究没有产生效果。当采用特定干预措施时,就业和家庭关系得到改善。
DTCs在项目内药物使用方面产生了有益的结果和影响。然而,关于DTCs对项目后药物和酒精使用以及对其他与毒品相关的生活领域影响的证据很少。如果有针对性,这些生活领域以及生活质量可能会通过DTCs得到改善。未来的研究是必要的。