Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Neuroimage. 2013 Sep;78:33-45. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.04.020. Epub 2013 Apr 13.
The current state of empirical investigations refers to consciousness as an all-or-none phenomenon. However, a recent theoretical account opens up this perspective by proposing a partial level (between nil and full) of conscious perception. In the well-studied case of single-word reading, short-lived exposure can trigger incomplete word-form recognition wherein letters fall short of forming a whole word in one's conscious perception thereby hindering word-meaning access and report. Hence, the processing from incomplete to complete word-form recognition straightforwardly mirrors a transition from partial to full-blown consciousness. We therefore hypothesized that this putative functional bottleneck to consciousness (i.e. the perceptual boundary between partial and full conscious perception) would emerge at a major key hub region for word-form recognition during reading, namely the left occipito-temporal junction. We applied a real-time staircase procedure and titrated subjective reports at the threshold between partial (letters) and full (whole word) conscious perception. This experimental approach allowed us to collect trials with identical physical stimulation, yet reflecting distinct perceptual experience levels. Oscillatory brain activity was monitored with magnetoencephalography and revealed that the transition from partial-to-full word-form perception was accompanied by alpha-band (7-11 Hz) power suppression in the posterior left occipito-temporal cortex. This modulation of rhythmic activity extended anteriorly towards the visual word form area (VWFA), a region whose selectivity for word-forms in perception is highly debated. The current findings provide electrophysiological evidence for a functional bottleneck to consciousness thereby empirically instantiating a recently proposed partial perspective on consciousness. Moreover, the findings provide an entirely new outlook on the functioning of the VWFA as a late bottleneck to full-blown conscious word-form perception.
当前的实证研究将意识视为一种全有或全无的现象。然而,最近的一种理论观点通过提出一种有意识知觉的部分水平(在零和全之间)来开拓了这一视角。在单字阅读的研究中,短暂的暴露可以引发不完全的字形识别,在这种情况下,字母无法在一个人的有意识知觉中形成一个完整的单词,从而阻碍了对单词意义的访问和报告。因此,从不完全的字形识别到完全的字形识别的处理过程直接反映了从部分意识到完全意识的转变。因此,我们假设,这种对意识的潜在功能瓶颈(即部分和完全有意识知觉之间的知觉边界)将出现在阅读过程中识别字形的主要关键枢纽区域,即左枕颞交界处。我们应用实时阶梯程序,并在部分(字母)和完全(整个单词)有意识知觉之间的阈值上滴定主观报告。这种实验方法允许我们收集具有相同物理刺激但反映不同知觉体验水平的试验。通过脑磁图监测到的振荡脑活动表明,从部分到全字知觉的转变伴随着左枕颞后皮质的 alpha 波段(7-11 Hz)功率抑制。这种节律活动的调制向前扩展到视觉词形区(VWFA),该区域的知觉中对词形的选择性存在很大争议。当前的发现为意识的功能瓶颈提供了电生理证据,从而实证地体现了最近提出的关于意识的部分观点。此外,这些发现为 VWFA 作为完全有意识的词形知觉的后期瓶颈的功能提供了全新的视角。