Janz N K, Becker M H, Haefner D P, Rutt W M, Weissfeld L A
Department of Health Behavior and Health Education, University of Michigan School of Public Health, Ann Arbor 48109-2029.
Am J Prev Med. 1990 Mar-Apr;6(2):84-92.
Although breast self-examination (BSE) continues to be recommended as an adjunct to clinical screening techniques for the early detection of breast cancer, little is known about events that might negatively influence long-term adherence. The primary aim of this investigation was to determine if regularity of BSE would decline after a benign breast biopsy. Analyses are based on 655 women: 83 women who self-discovered the breast problem by BSE, 179 women in whom the problem was discovered by the health care system, and a control group of 393 women who had no history of breast problems. Frequency of BSE was assessed over two six-month periods and collapsed into three categories--nonpractitioner, irregular practitioner, and regular practitioner. Results indicated that the percentage of women in the self-discovered group who reported decreased regularity of BSE was over three times higher than that found in the control group. The largest percentage increase in BSE frequency was evidenced by the health care-discovered group. Logistic regressions revealed that the biopsy experience was a more powerful indicator of subsequent BSE practice than either sociodemographic characteristics or whether one engaged in other preventive health behaviors. The data provide substantial evidence that a benign biopsy can affect BSE practice, with the direction and magnitude of the change influenced by mode of discovery of the breast problem, perceived degree of confidence in ability to perform BSE, and level of practice before the biopsy. Postbiopsy educational strategies incorporating these findings and targeted at specific subgroups are outlined.
尽管乳房自我检查(BSE)仍被推荐作为临床筛查技术的辅助手段用于早期发现乳腺癌,但对于可能对长期坚持产生负面影响的因素却知之甚少。本调查的主要目的是确定良性乳房活检后BSE的规律性是否会下降。分析基于655名女性:83名通过BSE自我发现乳房问题的女性,179名由医疗保健系统发现问题的女性,以及393名无乳房问题病史的女性组成的对照组。在两个六个月期间评估BSE的频率,并归纳为三类——不进行BSE者、不规律进行BSE者和规律进行BSE者。结果表明,自我发现组中报告BSE规律性下降的女性比例比对照组高出三倍多。医疗保健发现组的BSE频率增加百分比最大。逻辑回归显示,活检经历比社会人口统计学特征或是否进行其他预防性健康行为更能有力地预测随后的BSE行为。数据提供了充分的证据表明良性活检会影响BSE行为,这种变化的方向和程度受乳房问题的发现方式、对进行BSE能力的感知信心程度以及活检前的BSE实践水平影响。文中概述了结合这些发现并针对特定亚组的活检后教育策略。