Cardiovascular Center, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, MI, USA,
J Thromb Thrombolysis. 2014;37(2):171-6. doi: 10.1007/s11239-013-0934-8.
To more accurately quantify the proportion of anticoagulated patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) that may be inappropriately treated with warfarin for stroke prevention. Patients with AF have an increased risk of stroke, which is lowered by the use of warfarin. However there is likely more potential harm than benefit in patients that do not have additional stroke risk factors. Studies have described overuse of warfarin for stroke prophylaxis in lowest risk patients. However, many of those studies did not assess for electrical cardioversion (ECV) or radiofrequency ablation (RFA) as indications for warfarin therapy. Data from 1852 non-valvular AF patients treated with warfarin between October 2009 and October 2011 at seven anticoagulation centers participating in the Michigan Anticoagulation Quality Improvement Initiative registry were analyzed. Low risk AF patients were risk stratified using the CHADS2 scoring systems, with a score of zero representing lowest risk. 193 (10.4 %) of AF patients receiving warfarin were identified as having the lowest risk of stroke by the CHADS2 score. Of the patients with CHADS2 = 0, 130 (67.4 %) had undergone a recent ECV and/or RFA. Of all AF patients, only 63 (3.4 %) had a CHADS2 score of 0 and no recent ECV or RFA. The vast majority of AF patients receiving anticoagulation in this multi-center registry are doing so in accordance with national and international guidelines. In contrast to prior population-based studies, very few low risk patients are receiving inappropriate warfarin therapy for stroke prophylaxis in AF, when procedure-based indications are also considered.
为了更准确地量化接受华法林抗凝治疗的心房颤动(AF)患者中可能存在不适当的卒中预防治疗的比例。AF 患者发生卒中的风险增加,华法林的使用可以降低这种风险。然而,对于没有其他卒中危险因素的患者,其潜在危害可能大于益处。已有研究描述了在最低危患者中过度使用华法林进行卒中预防。然而,许多研究并未评估电复律(ECV)或射频消融(RFA)作为华法林治疗的适应证。分析了 2009 年 10 月至 2011 年 10 月间在参与密歇根州抗凝质量改善倡议注册研究的七个抗凝中心接受华法林治疗的 1852 例非瓣膜性 AF 患者的数据。使用 CHADS2 评分系统对低危 AF 患者进行风险分层,评分 0 代表最低危。193 例(10.4%)接受华法林治疗的 AF 患者被 CHADS2 评分确定为卒中风险最低。在 CHADS2=0 的患者中,有 130 例(67.4%)近期接受了 ECV 和/或 RFA。在所有 AF 患者中,仅有 63 例(3.4%)CHADS2 评分 0 且无近期 ECV 或 RFA。在这个多中心注册研究中,大多数接受抗凝治疗的 AF 患者均符合国家和国际指南。与之前的基于人群的研究不同,当考虑基于程序的适应证时,很少有低危患者接受不适当的华法林治疗来预防 AF 中的卒中。