Young Linda M, Anderson Rodney P
Ohio Northern University, Ada, OH 45810.
J Microbiol Biol Educ. 2010 Dec 20;11(2):107-12. doi: 10.1128/jmbe.v11i2.204. Print 2010.
This study evaluated the use of two different case study formats (clinically-oriented cases versus personally-oriented cases) to determine which was most effective in promoting long-term retention of clinically significant microbiology concepts, developing patient empathy, improving comprehension of patient compliance problems, and facilitating student understanding of transcultural health care concerns. The analysis was conducted in multiple sections of three different introductory microbiology classes targeting specific cohorts: nursing students, pharmacy students and other allied health students (pre-med, pre-PA, CLS, etc.). Retention of course content was determined by evaluation of multiple-choice and short answer examinations at least three weeks after completing case studies. Evaluation of patient empathy, understanding of patient compliance issues and transcultural health care concerns were determined via student surveys. The results of the study indicated that personalized cases significantly improved long-term retention of course content. In addition, student responses indicated that personalized case studies were more effective in developing patient empathy and aiding students in understanding issues patients have with complying with treatment recommendations. Finally, personalized case studies were effective tools for introducing students to the challenges of transcultural health care.
本研究评估了两种不同案例研究形式(临床导向案例与个人导向案例)的使用情况,以确定哪种形式在促进对具有临床意义的微生物学概念的长期记忆、培养患者同理心、提高对患者依从性问题的理解以及促进学生对跨文化医疗保健问题的理解方面最有效。该分析在针对特定群体的三门不同微生物学入门课程的多个班级中进行:护理专业学生、药学专业学生和其他联合健康专业学生(医学预科、医师助理预科、临床实验室科学等)。在完成案例研究至少三周后,通过多项选择题和简答题考试评估课程内容的记忆情况。通过学生调查来评估患者同理心、对患者依从性问题的理解以及跨文化医疗保健问题。研究结果表明,个性化案例显著提高了课程内容的长期记忆。此外,学生的回答表明,个性化案例研究在培养患者同理心以及帮助学生理解患者在遵循治疗建议方面遇到的问题方面更有效。最后,个性化案例研究是向学生介绍跨文化医疗保健挑战的有效工具。