Krieger N
Department of Biochemical and Environmental Health Sciences, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley 94720.
Soc Sci Med. 1990;30(12):1273-81. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(90)90307-e.
Despite controversy as to the biologic and/or social meaning of 'race' and 'sex', few public health studies have directly examined the impact of racial or gender discrimination on health. One plausible condition they might affect is hypertension, since stress and internalized anger may constitute important risk factors for this disease. The present investigation therefore sought to determine the feasibility of asking questions pertaining to race- and gender-biased treatment plus response to unfair treatment, and to assess their predictive value regarding self-reported high blood pressure. Using random-digit dialing, 51 black and 50 white women, ages 20-80, who resided in Alameda County, CA in 1987, were identified and interviewed by phone. Among black respondents, those who stated they usually accepted and kept quiet about unfair treatment were 4.4 times more likely to report hypertension than women who said they took action and talked to others (P = 0.01 for linear trend); no clear association existed among white respondents. The age-adjusted risk of high blood pressure among black respondents who recounted experiencing zero instances of race- and gender-biased treatment was 2.6 times greater than that of black women who reported one or more such instances (95% CI = 0.7, 10.5). Among white respondents, gender discrimination was not associated with hypertension. These results suggest that an internalized response to unfair treatment, plus non-reporting of race and gender discrimination, may constitute risk factors for high blood pressure among black women. They also bolster the view that subjective appraisal of stressors may be inversely associated with risk of hypertension.
尽管对于“种族”和“性别”的生物学和/或社会意义存在争议,但很少有公共卫生研究直接考察种族或性别歧视对健康的影响。它们可能影响的一个合理状况是高血压,因为压力和内化的愤怒可能构成该疾病的重要风险因素。因此,本调查旨在确定询问与种族和性别偏见治疗以及对不公平待遇的反应相关问题的可行性,并评估它们对自我报告的高血压的预测价值。利用随机数字拨号法,识别出了51名年龄在20 - 80岁之间、1987年居住在加利福尼亚州阿拉米达县的黑人女性和50名白人女性,并通过电话对她们进行了访谈。在黑人受访者中,那些表示通常接受不公平待遇并保持沉默的人报告患高血压的可能性是那些表示采取行动并与他人交谈的女性的4.4倍(线性趋势P = 0.01);在白人受访者中不存在明显关联。在讲述没有经历过种族和性别偏见治疗情况的黑人受访者中,经年龄调整后的高血压风险是报告经历过一次或多次此类情况的黑人女性的2.6倍(95%可信区间 = 0.7, 10.5)。在白人受访者中,性别歧视与高血压无关。这些结果表明,对不公平待遇的内化反应,加上不报告种族和性别歧视,可能构成黑人女性患高血压的风险因素。它们还支持了这样一种观点,即对应激源的主观评估可能与高血压风险呈负相关。