Dutton D, Gomby D, Meunier B
Department of Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, CA 94305.
Soc Sci Med. 1990;30(12):1297-311. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(90)90310-o.
This paper analyzes mothers' satisfaction with the cost of children's care in six widely-varying ambulatory settings: fee-for-service solo and group practices, a prepaid group, public clinics, hospital outpatient departments, and an emergency room. Data are from a household survey in Washington, DC and represent 638 children. Findings indicate significantly higher satisfaction with cost in public clinics than in solo practice, fee-for-service groups, and the emergency room, adjusting for patient characteristics, attitudes and financial coverage. In fee-for-service settings, both provider charges and out-of-pocket costs had a nonlinear relation to satisfaction with cost; to a point, increasing costs and charges were associated with decreasing satisfaction, but thereafter higher costs and charges appeared to lead, other things equal, to higher satisfaction. Out-of-pocket costs had a significantly greater negative effect on poor mothers' satisfaction than on the more affluent. Implications for current policy trends are discussed.
按服务收费的个体诊所和团体诊所、预付费团体诊所、公共诊所、医院门诊部以及急诊室。数据来自华盛顿特区的一项家庭调查,涵盖638名儿童。研究结果表明,在调整患者特征、态度和医保覆盖情况后,母亲们对公共诊所费用的满意度显著高于个体诊所、按服务收费的团体诊所和急诊室。在按服务收费的机构中,医疗服务提供者的收费和自付费用与费用满意度呈非线性关系;在一定程度上,费用和收费的增加与满意度的降低相关,但此后,在其他条件相同的情况下,更高的费用和收费似乎会带来更高的满意度。自付费用对贫困母亲满意度的负面影响比对富裕母亲的影响要大得多。本文还讨论了对当前政策趋势的影响。