Dutton D B, Gomby D, Fowles J
Med Care. 1985 Jul;23(7):894-912. doi: 10.1097/00005650-198507000-00006.
This article compares mothers' satisfaction with children's medical care in six widely varying settings: fee-for-service solo and group practices, prepaid group practice, public clinics, hospital outpatient departments, and emergency rooms. Data are from a household survey representing 700 children in Washington, D.C. Satisfaction with the physician's friendliness, competence, and personal care, as well as waiting time, atmosphere, and cost were examined, comparing how satisfaction levels varied in relation to patient attributes and also among medical settings. Findings revealed significant differences across settings, even controlling statistically for multiple patient characteristics. Satisfaction with interpersonal items was highest in fee-for-service settings, especially solo practice, whereas satisfaction with cost was highest in the public clinics, followed by the prepaid group practice. Previously published comparisons of utilization and health outcomes in the same settings revealed entirely different rankings. Together, these findings illustrate the multifaceted and paradoxical nature of health system performance.
按服务收费的个体诊所和团体诊所、预付费团体诊所、公共诊所、医院门诊部和急诊室。数据来自华盛顿特区一项涵盖700名儿童的家庭调查。研究考察了对医生的友好程度、专业能力、个性化护理以及等待时间、就医环境和费用的满意度,并比较了满意度水平如何因患者特征以及医疗环境的不同而有所变化。研究结果显示,即使在对多种患者特征进行统计学控制之后,不同医疗环境之间仍存在显著差异。对人际关系方面的满意度在按服务收费的环境中最高,尤其是个体诊所,而对费用的满意度在公共诊所最高,其次是预付费团体诊所。此前发表的关于相同医疗环境下医疗服务利用情况和健康结果的比较显示出完全不同的排名。这些研究结果共同说明了卫生系统绩效的多面性和矛盾性。