Department of Emergency Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University and Hospitals, Philadelphia, PA 19107, USA.
Am J Emerg Med. 2013 Jun;31(6):950-2. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2013.03.014. Epub 2013 May 16.
This study aimed to evaluate emergency medical physician's knowledge of the charges for the entirety of medical care provided to patients they treated and discharged from the emergency department (ED).
The study was administered in an academic ED. Patients were eligible for the study if they were discharged from the ED by the attending who first evaluated them. Following patient discharge from the ED, the attending physician and resident were asked to estimate the total billed to the patient (all charges billed to patient before adjustments for insurance provider or coverage status were applied). The median error of the physician's estimate was compared to their years of experience.
Physicians underestimated actual total charges 93% (127/136) of the time. The median estimate was 36% (IQR 23%-54%) of the actual final ED charge, representing a median underestimation of $1268 (IQR $766-$2347). There was no correlation between degree of error and postgraduate years of the physician.
This study demonstrated a significant underestimation of a patient's total charges by emergency medical physicians. There was no correlation in years of experience and ability to accurately estimate charges. While all physicians tended to underestimate charges, physicians tended to have good inter-rater agreement.
本研究旨在评估急诊医师对其在急诊科治疗并出院的患者的全部医疗费用的了解程度。
该研究在一所学术性急诊科进行。如果接受评估的主治医生将患者从急诊科出院,则患者有资格参加该研究。在患者从急诊科出院后,主治医生和住院医师被要求估计向患者开具的总账单(在对保险提供商或保险范围状况进行调整之前向患者开具的所有费用)。将医生估计的中位数误差与其工作年限进行比较。
医生的估计值在 93%(127/136)的时间内低估了实际总费用。中位数估计值为实际最终急诊费用的 36%(IQR 23%-54%),代表中位数低估了 1268 美元(IQR 766-2347 美元)。医生的错误程度与研究生年数之间没有相关性。
本研究表明,急诊医师对患者的总费用存在显著低估。工作年限与准确估计费用之间没有相关性。虽然所有医生都倾向于低估费用,但医生在估计费用方面的评分一致性较好。