Broadwater-Hollifield Camille, Gren Lisa H, Porucznik Christina A, Youngquist Scott T, Sundwall David N, Madsen Troy E
Department of Family and Preventive Medicine, Division of Public Health, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA.
Department of Family and Preventive Medicine, Division of Public Health, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA.
Am J Emerg Med. 2014 Jun;32(6):498-506. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2014.01.044. Epub 2014 Feb 3.
We investigated emergency physician knowledge of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) reimbursement for common tests ordered and procedures performed in the emergency department (ED), determined the relative accuracy of their estimation, and reported the impact of perceived costs on physicians' ordering and prescribing behavior.
We distributed an online survey to 189 emergency physicians in 11 EDs across multiple institutions. The survey asked respondents to estimate reimbursement rates for a limited set of medical tests and procedures, rate their level of current cost knowledge, and determine the effect of health expenditures on their medical decision making. We calculated relative accuracy of cost knowledge as a percent difference of participant estimation of cost from the CMS reimbursement rate.
Ninety-seven physicians participated in the study. Most respondents (65%) perceived their knowledge of costs as inadequate, and 39.3% indicated that beliefs about cost impacted their ordering behavior. Eighty percent of physicians surveyed were unable to estimate 25% of the costs within ±25%, and no physicians estimated at least 50% of costs within 25% of the CMS reimbursement and only 17.3% of medical services were estimated correctly within ±25% by 1 or more physicians.
Most emergency physicians indicated they should consider cost in their decision making but have a limited knowledge of cost estimates used by CMS to calculate reimbursement rates. Interventions that are easily accessible and applicable in the ED setting are needed to educate physicians about costs, reimbursement, and charges associated with the care they deliver.
我们调查了急诊医生对医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心(CMS)针对急诊科(ED)常见检查和操作的报销情况的了解,确定了他们估计的相对准确性,并报告了感知成本对医生开单和开药行为的影响。
我们向多个机构的11个急诊科的189名急诊医生发放了在线调查问卷。该调查要求受访者估计一组有限的医学检查和操作的报销率,评估他们当前的成本知识水平,并确定医疗支出对其医疗决策的影响。我们将成本知识的相对准确性计算为参与者对成本的估计与CMS报销率之间的百分比差异。
97名医生参与了该研究。大多数受访者(65%)认为他们对成本的了解不足,39.3%表示对成本的看法影响了他们的开单行为。80%的受访医生无法在±25%的范围内估计25%的成本,没有医生能在CMS报销率的25%范围内估计至少50%的成本,只有17.3%的医疗服务被1名或多名医生在±25%的范围内正确估计。
大多数急诊医生表示他们在决策时应考虑成本,但对CMS用于计算报销率的成本估计了解有限。需要在急诊科环境中易于获取和应用的干预措施,以教育医生了解与他们提供的护理相关的成本、报销和收费情况。