Konaka S, Shimizu S, Iizawa M, Ohkawara H, Kato O, Ashikari J, Fukushima N
Department of Therapeutics for End Stage Organ Dysfunction, Osaka University, Suita, Japan.
Transplant Proc. 2013 May;45(4):1295-300. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2013.01.016.
When the Japanese Organ Transplantation Act was issued, the Japanese Organ Transplantation Network (JOT) was established in 1997. JOT lists recipients, assesses and manages organ donors, and educates publics and headquarters for organ donations. JOT procurement transplant coordinators (PTC) play roles in obtaining consent from relatives for organ donation, donor evaluation and management, organ recovery management, organ transport, and care of donor families during and after donation. Every prefecture has at least one PTC who is mainly working in public education and hospital development. They also help the JOT PTC at the time of organ procurement. Most prefectures commission hospital staff in the procurement hospital to be an in-hospital PTC (In-Hp PTC), who make their hospital staff aware of organ donation and support organ procurement. Although the Act was revised in 2010 with brain-dead organ donation increased from 13 to 44 cases yearly, the number was still extremely smaller than other developed countries. In these circumstances, In-Hp PTC may play greater roles to increase donation and smooth procurement procedures Our primary aim was to describe the current status of In-Hp PTC in Japan.
Between December 15, 2011, and January 31, 2012, we invited 1889 In-Hp PTC to complete a letter survey using a self-designed questionnaire. In all, 56 In-Hp PTC (40%) completed and returned it.
The occupation of the respondents was nurse (66%), physician (18%), or other (16%). Although 52% of respondents belonged to the hospital, which was designated for brain-death organ donation by the government, only 46% had any experience with a cadaveric donor. Only 2% were full-time In-Hp PTC. They mainly played a role in preparing their own manual for organ procurement (57%), providing in-hospital lectures (44%) or their own simulation exercise (29%), as well as coordinating donation cases. Although 77% had attended seminar about organ donation provided by JOT or the prefecture PTC, 93% wanted more professional education. However, it was difficult for them to attend these activities, to manage a rare and sudden donation case, and to find time to learn about organ donation because they had another post. The topics that they wanted to learn were donor family care (72%), overall organ/tissue donation procedures (65%), the role of In-Hp PTC (67%), simulations of donation (65%), legislation and social system of organ donation (61%), medical indications for donation (61%), current status of donation and transplantation in Japan (57%), donor management (56%), and case studies (49%). There were significant variations in the topics of interest among the occupations. As they had another post, they could find only a short period (1 or 2 days) to take professional education, such as lectures. Therefore, it was difficult for them to attend practical on-the-job training.
To establish an organ procurement system and increase organ donation, In-Hp PTC have important roles in Japan. However, none is a full-time In-Hp PTC. Most In-Hp PTC require more professional education. A systematic education program for each occupation must be established soon.
日本《器官移植法》颁布后,日本器官移植网络(JOT)于1997年成立。JOT负责列出受者名单,评估和管理器官捐献者,并对公众和总部进行器官捐献教育。JOT的采购移植协调员(PTC)在获取亲属的器官捐献同意、捐献者评估与管理、器官获取管理、器官运输以及捐献期间和之后对捐献者家属的照料等方面发挥作用。每个县至少有一名主要从事公众教育和医院发展工作的PTC。在器官获取时,他们也会协助JOT的PTC。大多数县委托采购医院的医院工作人员担任院内PTC(In-Hp PTC),这些人员让医院工作人员了解器官捐献并支持器官获取工作。尽管该法在2010年进行了修订,脑死亡器官捐献数量从每年13例增加到44例,但这一数字仍远低于其他发达国家。在这种情况下,院内PTC可能在增加捐献和简化获取程序方面发挥更大作用。我们的主要目的是描述日本院内PTC的现状。
在2011年12月15日至2012年1月31日期间,我们邀请1889名院内PTC使用自行设计的问卷完成信函调查。共有56名院内PTC(40%)完成并返回了问卷。
受访者的职业为护士(66%)、医生(18%)或其他(16%)。尽管52%的受访者所在医院是政府指定的脑死亡器官捐献医院,但只有46%的人有过尸体捐献者相关经历。只有2%是全职院内PTC。他们主要在编写自己的器官获取手册(57%)、开展院内讲座(44%)或自己的模拟演练(29%)以及协调捐献案例方面发挥作用。尽管77%的人参加过JOT或县PTC提供的器官捐献研讨会,但93%的人希望接受更多专业教育。然而,由于他们还有其他工作岗位,很难参加这些活动、处理罕见且突然的捐献案例以及抽出时间学习器官捐献知识。他们想学习的主题包括捐献者家属照料(72%)、器官/组织整体捐献程序(65%)、院内PTC的作用(67%)、捐献模拟(65%)、器官捐献的立法和社会制度(61%)、捐献的医学指征(61%)、日本捐献与移植的现状(57%)、捐献者管理(56%)以及案例研究(49%)。不同职业在感兴趣的主题方面存在显著差异。由于他们有其他工作岗位,只能抽出很短时间(1或2天)参加专业教育,如讲座。因此,他们很难参加实际的在职培训。
为建立器官获取系统并增加器官捐献,院内PTC在日本发挥着重要作用。然而,没有全职的院内PTC。大多数院内PTC需要更多专业教育。必须尽快为每个职业建立系统的教育项目。