Gschmeidler Brigitte, Flatscher-Thoeni Magdalena
Department of Public Health and Health Technology Assessment, UMIT - Private University of Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, Hall, Tirol, Austria,
J Genet Couns. 2013 Dec;22(6):741-52. doi: 10.1007/s10897-013-9610-6. Epub 2013 Jun 1.
Genetic counseling is gaining in importance with the increasing application of genetic testing for diagnosis and clinical treatment. Genetic counseling often raises ethical and professional challenges and prior research has categorized them into 16 domains. The purpose of this study was to analyze the situation in Austria on the basis of these challenges and discuss it in the national and international context. While in some countries there is a special profession for genetic counseling, in Austria it is provided by medical geneticists or other physicians in the context of their specialization. Psychosocial professionals might be consulted or brought in if necessary. Results from 95 survey respondents (including physicians and psychosocial professionals) revealed a greater interest in the topic of genetic counseling by medical specialists other than medical geneticists. The most frequently encountered challenges among physicians were informed consent, organizational constraints, withholding information, and attaining/maintaining proficiency. The psychosocial professionals experienced maintaining proficiency and organizational constraints as the prevalent challenges. Additional findings and practice implications are presented.
随着基因检测在诊断和临床治疗中的应用日益广泛,遗传咨询的重要性与日俱增。遗传咨询常常引发伦理和专业方面的挑战,先前的研究已将这些挑战归类为16个领域。本研究的目的是基于这些挑战分析奥地利的情况,并在国内和国际背景下进行讨论。在一些国家,遗传咨询是一个特殊的职业,而在奥地利,它由医学遗传学家或其他专科医生在其专业范围内提供。如有必要,可能会咨询或引入心理社会专业人员。95名调查受访者(包括医生和心理社会专业人员)的结果显示,除医学遗传学家之外的医学专家对遗传咨询主题更感兴趣。医生中最常遇到的挑战是知情同意、组织限制、信息隐瞒以及达到/保持专业水平。心理社会专业人员则将保持专业水平和组织限制视为普遍存在的挑战。本文还介绍了其他研究结果及实践意义。