Fosco M, Gualdrini G, Ben Ayad R
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rizzoli Orthopaedic Institute, Via Pupilli 1, 40136, Bologna, Italy,
Musculoskelet Surg. 2014 Jun;98(1):45-52. doi: 10.1007/s12306-013-0272-1. Epub 2013 Jun 1.
This retrospective study was performed to assess the effectiveness of active immunostimulation therapy with bacterial immunotherapy (BIT) in treatment for chronic osteomyelitis (COM).
We analyze 154 patients affected by COM and treated with BIT from 1995 to 2009 at our Institution. Using Cierny and Mader classification, patients were divided according to their clinical status and anatomic nature of septic process. The data were analyzed considering several confounding factors, such as antibiotic therapy and hyperbaric oxygen therapy combined with the administration of BIT. According to clinical and radiographic parameters, patients were considered as unchanged, improved, or healed.
After a mean follow-up of 40.4 months (median 38 months), healing was achieved in 41.6 % of cases. Multivariate statistical analysis showed that patient's clinical status is the most important prognostic factor of responding (p < 0.0005) and healing (p = 0.008) after therapy. The best healing rate (62 % of cases) was achieved in patients with a normal clinical condition (Cierny-Mader group A); it was worse (20 % of cases) in those patients with a compromised clinical status (Cierny-Mader group B). There was no healing case in group C.
The results show the effectiveness of BIT in treatment of patients affected by COM with uncompromised clinical status. The use of this therapy must be assessed critically in patients with alterations in clinical conditions.
本回顾性研究旨在评估细菌免疫疗法(BIT)主动免疫刺激疗法治疗慢性骨髓炎(COM)的有效性。
我们分析了1995年至2009年在我院接受BIT治疗的154例COM患者。采用Cierny和Mader分类法,根据患者的临床状况和感染过程的解剖性质进行分组。分析数据时考虑了几个混杂因素,如抗生素治疗、高压氧治疗以及与BIT联合使用的情况。根据临床和影像学参数,将患者分为病情未改变、改善或治愈。
平均随访40.4个月(中位数38个月)后,41.6%的病例实现了愈合。多变量统计分析表明,患者的临床状况是治疗后反应(p < 0.0005)和愈合(p = 0.008)的最重要预后因素。临床状况正常的患者(Cierny-Mader A组)愈合率最高(62%的病例);临床状况受损的患者(Cierny-Mader B组)愈合率较低(20%的病例)。C组无愈合病例。
结果表明BIT对临床状况未受损的COM患者治疗有效。对于临床状况改变的患者,必须严格评估这种疗法的使用。