Behavioral Psychopharmacology Research Laboratory, McLean Hospital, Belmont, MA 02138, USA.
Psychiatry Res. 2013 Aug 30;213(2):142-53. doi: 10.1016/j.pscychresns.2013.03.005. Epub 2013 Jun 12.
Over the past two decades, many magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) studies reported lower N-acetylaspartate (NAA) in key brain regions of patients with schizophrenia (SZ) compared to healthy subjects. A smaller number of studies report no difference in NAA. Many sources of variance may contribute to these discordant results including heterogeneity of the SZ subject populations and methodological differences such as MRS acquisition parameters, and post-acquisition analytic methods. The current study reviewed proton MRS literature reporting measurements of NAA in SZ with a focus on methodology. Studies which reported lower NAA were significantly more likely to have used longer echo times (TEs), while studies with shorter TEs reported no concentration difference. This suggests that NAA quantitation using MRS was affected by the choice of TE, and that published MRS literature reporting NAA in SZ using a long TE is confounded by apparent differential T2 relaxation effects between SZ and healthy control groups. Future MRS studies should measure T2 relaxation times. This would allow for spectral concentration measurements to be appropriately corrected for these relaxation effects. In addition, as metabolite concentration and T2 relaxation times are completely independent variables, this could offer distinct information about the metabolite of interest.
在过去的二十年中,许多磁共振波谱(MRS)研究报告称,与健康受试者相比,精神分裂症(SZ)患者的关键大脑区域中的 N-乙酰天冬氨酸(NAA)水平较低。少数研究报告 NAA 没有差异。许多变异源可能导致这些不一致的结果,包括 SZ 受试者人群的异质性以及 MRS 采集参数和采集后分析方法等方法学差异。本研究回顾了报告 SZ 中 NAA 测量值的质子 MRS 文献,重点关注方法学。报告 NAA 较低的研究显著更有可能使用更长的回波时间(TE),而使用较短 TE 的研究则没有报告浓度差异。这表明 MRS 中 NAA 的定量受到 TE 选择的影响,并且使用长 TE 报告 SZ 中 NAA 的已发表 MRS 文献受到 SZ 和健康对照组之间明显不同的 T2 弛豫效应的干扰。未来的 MRS 研究应测量 T2 弛豫时间。这将允许对光谱浓度测量进行适当的校正,以消除这些弛豫效应的影响。此外,由于代谢物浓度和 T2 弛豫时间是完全独立的变量,因此这可以提供有关感兴趣代谢物的独特信息。