Morrongiello Barbara A, Bell Melissa, Butac Michael, Kane Alexa
Psychology Department, University of Guelph, , Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
Inj Prev. 2014 Feb;20(1):16-20. doi: 10.1136/injuryprev-2012-040721. Epub 2013 Jun 22.
Enhancing caregivers' awareness of children's injury risks and increasing knowledge about strategies for injury prevention often involve presenting parents with written materials and accompanying images.
To assess parents' appraisals of different variations of images and identify those features that enhance their attention to safety messages.
Eight images showing risk situations were taken from the A Million Messages safety education parent-directed programme in Canada and modified to create a corresponding image that clearly showed negative consequences for the child, and facial expressions of fear and/or upset. Mothers with young children were presented with the eight pairs of images (negative consequence vs risk situation) and asked to select the best accompaniment to a safety message and to provide an explanation for their choice. Each image was then also rated for fit to the safety message, communication of danger, emotional arousal and attention elicitation.
The images depicting negative consequences were chosen for most comparisons (78%) and higher scores were assigned to these images for all four features rated by parents (danger communicated, emotions evoked, attention elicitation and fit to the safety message). Moreover, ratings of danger, emotions and attention predicted 'fit to safety message' scores.
Depicting negative consequences and showing negative emotions is important to maximise the effectiveness of images in communicating danger and evoking attention and concern when targeting parents with child-safety messaging.
提高照顾者对儿童受伤风险的认识并增加有关伤害预防策略的知识,通常需要向家长提供书面材料及附带图片。
评估家长对不同图片变体的评价,并确定那些能增强他们对安全信息关注度的特征。
从加拿大“百万条信息”家长指导安全教育项目中选取八张显示风险情况的图片,并进行修改,以创建一张相应图片,清晰展示对孩子的负面后果以及恐惧和/或不安的面部表情。向有幼儿的母亲展示这八组图片(负面后果与风险情况),并要求她们选择安全信息的最佳配图,并为自己的选择提供解释。然后,对每张图片在与安全信息的契合度、危险传达、情绪唤起和注意力吸引方面进行评分。
在大多数比较中(78%),描绘负面后果的图片被选中,并且家长对所有四个评分特征(危险传达、情绪唤起、注意力吸引和与安全信息的契合度)都给这些图片打了更高的分数。此外,危险、情绪和注意力的评分预测了“与安全信息的契合度”得分。
描绘负面后果并展示负面情绪对于在向家长传达儿童安全信息时最大化图片在传达危险、唤起关注和担忧方面的效果非常重要。