Kerbage H, Bahadori S, Léger J, Carel J-C, Purper Ouakil D
Service de psychiatrie, hôpital hôtel-Dieu de France, faculté de Médecine, université Saint-Joseph, boulevard Alfred-Naccache, Achrafieh, Beyrouth, Liban.
Service de psychopathologie de l'enfant et de l'adolescent, hôpital Robert-Debré, AP-HP, 48, boulevard Sérurier, 75019 Paris, France; Inserm U675/U894, équipe 1 « Analyse génétique et clinique des comportements addictifs et psychiatriques », centre psychiatrie et neurosciences, 2 ter, rue d'Alésia, 75014 Paris, France.
Encephale. 2014 Feb;40(1):56-61. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2013.04.007. Epub 2013 Jun 28.
SSRIs have been shown to affect bone health in adults, but this has been poorly studied in children. Given the frequency of SSRI prescription in children and adolescents, it is crucial to evaluate the impact of SSRIs on bone growth because the bone mass attained early in life is the most important predictor of a normal bone constitution. Experimental studies have demonstrated a direct functional role of serotonin in bone metabolism, independently of hyperprolactinemia or growth hormone levels. We have reviewed the literature on serotonin and bone metabolism, including experimental studies, clinical studies in adults as well as in the pediatric population.
Experimental studies have shown that 5-HT transporter (5-HTT) is expressed in all kind of bone cells and is highly specific of the 5-HT recapture. 5-HTT inhibition by the SSRIs in these cells affects their function in vitro. Even though a few studies have suggested exposure to SSRIs could be beneficial by an anabolic effect on the trabecular bone, more concluding studies have demonstrated that SSRIs negatively affect bone growth, resulting in a specific bone phenotype including a reduction in bone mass, an altered bone architecture, and decreased mechanical properties. This phenotype is most probably the consequence of a decrease in bone formation, rather than an increase in bone resorption and is a direct and dose-dependent effect. However, many aspects of this bone effect of 5-HTT inhibition need to be further clarified, including the signal ways for 5-HTT and 5-HT receptors, origins of 5-HT in bone, and methods to isolate the inhibitory effect of 5-HTT specifically on bone.
Metabolic and neuroendocrine side effects have been documented in children and adolescents taking SSRIs but the specific and direct effect of these molecules on bone metabolism has been poorly studied in this population. In adults, clinical studies have shown an association between the use of SSRIs and bone demineralization as well as reduction in bone mass, especially in the elderly and post-menopausal women. However, depression itself has been associated with a lower bone mass and increased risk of osteoporosis. In children, case reports show a decrease in growth due to a decreased secretion of growth hormone, but not by a direct effect. One cross-sectional study suggests a decrease in bone mass following SSRI treatment that is independent of variation in prolactin levels, but without elevation of fracture risk. These results, however, need to be replicated in further studies.
Our review shows that experimental studies have demonstrated the implication of the serotonin system in bone metabolism. Mice with genetic disruption of 5-HTT have a bone phenotype of decreased bone mass, altered architecture, and decreased mechanical properties. Clinical studies exploring the effect of SSRIs on bone metabolism are scarce in children. However, results in adults tend to show a deleterious effect in the elderly. Regarding the frequency of SSRI prescription in the pediatric population, it is becoming urgent to better explore the effect of SSRIs on bone growth of children, as it can have major implications on the ulterior follow-up and on the precautions to take.
选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRIs)已被证明会影响成年人的骨骼健康,但在儿童中这方面的研究较少。鉴于儿童和青少年中SSRIs的处方频率,评估SSRIs对骨骼生长的影响至关重要,因为生命早期获得的骨量是正常骨骼构成的最重要预测指标。实验研究表明,血清素在骨代谢中具有直接的功能作用,与高泌乳素血症或生长激素水平无关。我们回顾了关于血清素与骨代谢的文献,包括实验研究、成人及儿科人群的临床研究。
实验研究表明,5-羟色胺转运体(5-HTT)在所有类型的骨细胞中均有表达,且对5-羟色胺的重摄取具有高度特异性。SSRIs对这些细胞中5-HTT的抑制会在体外影响其功能。尽管有一些研究表明,接触SSRIs可能通过对小梁骨的合成代谢作用而有益,但更多结论性研究表明,SSRIs会对骨骼生长产生负面影响,导致特定的骨表型,包括骨量减少、骨结构改变和力学性能下降。这种表型很可能是骨形成减少的结果,而非骨吸收增加的结果,并且是一种直接的剂量依赖性效应。然而,5-HTT抑制对骨骼的这种影响的许多方面仍需进一步阐明,包括5-HTT和5-羟色胺受体的信号通路、骨中5-羟色胺的来源以及特异性分离5-HTT对骨骼抑制作用的方法。
在服用SSRIs的儿童和青少年中,已记录到代谢和神经内分泌副作用,但这些分子对骨代谢的具体直接影响在该人群中研究较少。在成年人中,临床研究表明,使用SSRIs与骨脱矿质以及骨量减少有关,尤其是在老年人和绝经后女性中。然而,抑郁症本身与较低的骨量和骨质疏松风险增加有关。在儿童中,病例报告显示生长激素分泌减少导致生长减缓,但并非直接影响。一项横断面研究表明,SSRIs治疗后骨量减少,这与泌乳素水平的变化无关,但骨折风险并未升高。然而,这些结果需要在进一步的研究中得到验证。
我们的综述表明,实验研究已证明血清素系统参与骨代谢。5-HTT基因缺失的小鼠具有骨量减少、结构改变和力学性能下降的骨表型。在儿童中,探索SSRIs对骨代谢影响的临床研究很少。然而,成人的研究结果倾向于表明对老年人有有害影响。鉴于儿科人群中SSRIs的处方频率,迫切需要更好地探索SSRIs对儿童骨骼生长的影响,因为这可能对后续随访和预防措施产生重大影响。