Department of Psychology, DePaul University, Chicago, IL 60614, USA.
J Pers Soc Psychol. 2013 Jul;105(1):1-23. doi: 10.1037/a0032967.
In this article we explore how beliefs about system ideals and the achievement of those ideals differentially predict system justification among low- and high-status groups. Our goal was to reconcile how people can promote system ideals such as equal opportunities for all and at the same time recognize that group-based disparities are, in part, due to these unfulfilled ideals. Three studies examined whether people perceived a discrepancy between a system's ideal goals and its achievement of those goals. Everyone endorsed these goal ideals more than they believed that the goals were being achieved; however, this discrepancy was larger for low-status people. The larger the perceived discrepancy, the more dissatisfied people were with the system and the more likely they were to support hierarchy-attenuating policies. Studies 2 and 3 also examined people's motivation for endorsing goal ideals. People of all statuses endorsed system ideals to promote an ideal system more than to legitimize the actual system (Study 2); however, high-status people were slightly more likely to endorse system ideals to legitimize the actual system than low-status people (Study 3). In summary, low-status people were more likely than high-status people to recognize discrepancies between system goals and system outcomes, show dissatisfaction with the American system, and prefer policies that would attenuate extant hierarchies.
在本文中,我们探讨了信念对系统理想的影响,以及这些信念对高低社会地位群体的系统辩护的差异预测。我们的目标是调和人们如何能够促进系统理想,如为所有人提供平等机会,同时认识到群体差异部分是由于这些未实现的理想造成的。三项研究检验了人们是否认为系统的理想目标与其实现目标之间存在差距。每个人都更支持这些目标理想,而不是认为这些目标正在实现;然而,对于低地位的人来说,这种差距更大。感知到的差距越大,人们对系统的不满就越大,他们就越有可能支持削弱等级制度的政策。研究 2 和 3 还考察了人们支持目标理想的动机。所有地位的人都更倾向于为了促进理想系统而支持系统理想,而不是为了使实际系统合法化(研究 2);然而,与低地位的人相比,高地位的人稍微更有可能为了使实际系统合法化而支持系统理想(研究 3)。总之,与高地位的人相比,低地位的人更有可能认识到系统目标和系统结果之间的差距,对美国制度不满,并倾向于采取减轻现有等级制度的政策。