Andrews J Matthew, Abdolell Mohamed, Norman Richard W
Department of Urology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS;
Can Urol Assoc J. 2013 May-Jun;7(5-6):E402-6. doi: 10.5489/cuaj.1348.
Scholarly research is a key component of Canadian urology residency. Through comparison of scholarly performance of urology residents before residency with that achieved during residency, we aimed to elicit predictive factors for completion of research activities.
Electronic surveys were sent to 152 urology residents of 11 accredited Canadian programs. Survey questions pertained to post-graduate training year (PGY), formal education, scholarly activity completed before and after the start of residency, protected/dedicated research time, structured research curriculum and pursuit of fellowship training.
Surveys were completed by 42 residents from 10 programs. Only 26% of residents had a structured research curriculum, 38% a dedicated research rotation and 43% protected research time. We found that 45% of residents published at least 1 manuscript so far during residency (mean 1.14 ± 0.32), and 43% submitted at least 1 manuscript (mean 0.86 ± 0.25). During residency, 62% of residents completed ≥1 formal research presentation (median number 1.5; range: 0-≥10). Only the level of PGY significantly affected the number of manuscripts published (p < 0.001) and number of formal research presentations (p < 0.001) completed during residency. In total, 86% of residents planning to pursue fellowship training had a mean number of publications and presentations during residency of 1.25 ± 0.37 and 2.25 ± 0.54, respectively.
Level of PGY significantly affected quantitative scholarly activity, but the numbers and types of presentations performed prior to residency, completion of an honours or graduate degree and plans to pursue fellowship training did not.
学术研究是加拿大泌尿外科住院医师培训的关键组成部分。通过比较泌尿外科住院医师培训前与培训期间的学术表现,我们旨在找出完成研究活动的预测因素。
向加拿大11个经认可项目的152名泌尿外科住院医师发送电子调查问卷。调查问题涉及研究生培训年份(PGY)、正规教育、住院医师培训开始前后完成的学术活动、受保护/专门的研究时间、结构化研究课程以及进修培训的追求。
来自10个项目的42名住院医师完成了调查。只有26%的住院医师有结构化研究课程,38%有专门的研究轮转,43%有受保护的研究时间。我们发现,45%的住院医师在住院医师培训期间至少发表了1篇论文(平均1.14±0.32),43%的住院医师至少提交了1篇论文(平均0.86±0.25)。在住院医师培训期间,62%的住院医师完成了≥1次正式研究报告(中位数为1.5;范围:0-≥10)。只有PGY水平对住院医师培训期间发表的论文数量(p<0.001)和完成的正式研究报告数量(p<0.001)有显著影响。总体而言,计划参加进修培训的住院医师中,86%在住院医师培训期间的平均发表论文数和报告数分别为1.25±0.37和2.25±0.54。
PGY水平对定量学术活动有显著影响,但住院医师培训前进行的报告数量和类型、荣誉学位或研究生学位的完成情况以及进修培训计划则没有影响。