Department of Neurology, University of Heidelberg, UniversitätsMedizin Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany.
Cerebrovasc Dis. 2013;35(6):544-53. doi: 10.1159/000350725. Epub 2013 Jul 6.
Cross-sectional studies have shown an association between the severity of age-related white matter change (ARWMC) and lower body motor function. However, the association between prevalent ARWMC and incident deterioration of balance and gait remains insufficiently investigated. This study investigates if the degree of prevalent ARWMC has a differential effect on lower body motor function as it changes over time, hypothesizing that individuals with more severe baseline white matter pathology experience greater clinical deterioration independent of potential confounders. This is of clinical relevance: given the increasing use of neuroimaging, incidental white matter pathology is common; being able to delineate natural trajectories of balance and gait function given ARWMC may improve patient advice and help optimize allocation of care.
639 non-disabled elderly individuals with prevalent ARWMC (grading of severity of ARWMC using the Fazekas scale) were followed up yearly for 3 years, as part of the Leukoaraiosis and Disability Study. The primary outcome variable, reflecting the temporal course of gait and balance function, was the change of scores on the Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) over time versus the severity of ARWMC. We used linear mixed modelling to analyse change over time. Explorative analysis was carried out investigating the effect of age on potential deterioration of gait and balance function. We used propensity scores to adjust for multiple confounders that affect both the exposure (i.e. ARWMC) and outcome.
Subjects' lower body motor function deteriorated by 2.6% per year. However, after adjustment for baseline motor impairment and potential confounders, only subjects with moderate [-0.22 points per year on the SPPB (equals -2.3%); 95% CI -0.35 to -0.09, p < 0.001] or severe [-0.46 points per year (equals -4.7%); 95% CI -0.63 to -0.28, p < 0.0001] ARWMC show a loss of function. Age shows differential effects: relatively younger elderly subjects have similar temporal dynamics in SPPB change independent of their individual degree of ARWMC severity; however, subjects with severe ARWMC and who are older than 75.9 years deteriorate significantly more rapidly than their counterparts with only mild or moderate white matter pathology.
Only moderate and severe ARWMC is independently associated - on average - with a deterioration of gait and balance. Albeit the possibility of unmeasured confounding and other methodological constraints, there is nonetheless evidence of large interindividual variability: some subjects with moderate or severe ARWMC stay stable over time or even show improvement. Furthermore, there is explorative analysis showing that younger elderly subjects may be able to better compensate even severe ARWMC. These individuals' gait and balance function stays relatively stable over time, whereas their older counterparts deteriorate significantly. This may point towards a threshold effect given ARWMC.
横断面研究表明,与年龄相关的脑白质改变(ARWMC)的严重程度与下半身运动功能之间存在关联。然而,普遍存在的 ARWMC 与平衡和步态恶化之间的关联仍未得到充分研究。本研究调查了普遍存在的 ARWMC 是否会因下半身运动功能随时间的变化而产生不同的影响,假设基线白质病变程度更严重的个体在不受潜在混杂因素影响的情况下,经历更大的临床恶化。这具有临床相关性:鉴于神经影像学的应用日益增多,偶发性的白质病变很常见;能够描绘 ARWMC 下平衡和步态功能的自然轨迹,可能会改善患者建议,并有助于优化护理资源的分配。
639 名无残疾的老年人存在普遍的 ARWMC(使用 Fazekas 量表评估 ARWMC 的严重程度),作为 Leukoaraiosis 和 Disability 研究的一部分,每年进行随访 3 年。主要结局变量反映了步态和平衡功能的时间变化轨迹,是随着时间的推移,SPPB 评分的变化,反映了步态和平衡功能的时间变化轨迹。我们使用线性混合模型来分析随时间的变化。进行了探索性分析,以研究年龄对潜在步态和平衡功能恶化的影响。我们使用倾向评分来调整影响暴露(即 ARWMC)和结局的多个混杂因素。
研究对象的下半身运动功能每年恶化 2.6%。然而,在调整了基线运动障碍和潜在混杂因素后,只有中等到严重的 ARWMC 患者的 SPPB 评分每年下降[中度 ARWMC 为每年 0.22 分(相当于 2.3%;95%CI -0.35 至 -0.09,p<0.001);严重 ARWMC 为每年 0.46 分(相当于 4.7%;95%CI -0.63 至 -0.28,p<0.0001)]。年龄显示出不同的影响:相对年轻的老年人,无论其个体 ARWMC 严重程度如何,其 SPPB 变化的时间动态都相似;然而,年龄较大且 ARWMC 严重的患者,其功能恶化速度明显快于仅有轻度或中度白质病变的患者。
只有中度和严重的 ARWMC 与步态和平衡的恶化独立相关(平均而言)。尽管存在未测量的混杂因素和其他方法学限制,但仍有大量个体间变异性的证据:一些中等到严重的 ARWMC 患者在一段时间内保持稳定,甚至有所改善。此外,探索性分析表明,年轻的老年人可能能够更好地代偿甚至严重的 ARWMC。这些患者的步态和平衡功能在一段时间内相对稳定,而他们的老年患者则明显恶化。这可能指向 ARWMC 下的阈值效应。