Key Laboratory of Agricultural and Environmental Microbiology, Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China.
Appl Environ Microbiol. 2013 Oct;79(19):5962-9. doi: 10.1128/AEM.01282-13. Epub 2013 Jul 19.
Ever since Carl Woese introduced the use of 16S rRNA genes for determining the phylogenetic relationships of prokaryotes, this method has been regarded as the "gold standard" in both microbial phylogeny and ecology studies. However, intragenomic heterogeneity within 16S rRNA genes has been reported in many investigations and is believed to bias the estimation of prokaryotic diversity. In the current study, 2,013 completely sequenced genomes of bacteria and archaea were analyzed and intragenomic heterogeneity was found in 952 genomes (585 species), with 87.5% of the divergence detected being below the 1% level. In particular, some extremophiles (thermophiles and halophiles) were found to harbor highly divergent 16S rRNA genes. Overestimation caused by 16S rRNA gene intragenomic heterogeneity was evaluated at different levels using the full-length and partial 16S rRNA genes usually chosen as targets for pyrosequencing. The result indicates that, at the unique level, full-length 16S rRNA genes can produce an overestimation of as much as 123.7%, while at the 3% level, an overestimation of 12.9% for the V6 region may be introduced. Further analysis showed that intragenomic heterogeneity tends to concentrate in specific positions, with the V1 and V6 regions suffering the most intragenomic heterogeneity and the V4 and V5 regions suffering the least intragenomic heterogeneity in bacteria. This is the most up-to-date overview of the diversity of 16S rRNA genes within prokaryotic genomes. It not only provides general guidance on how much overestimation can be introduced when applying 16S rRNA gene-based methods, due to its intragenomic heterogeneity, but also recommends that, for bacteria, this overestimation be minimized using primers targeting the V4 and V5 regions.
自从卡尔·沃斯(Carl Woese)引入 16S rRNA 基因用于确定原核生物的系统发育关系以来,该方法一直被认为是微生物系统发育和生态学研究的“金标准”。然而,许多研究报告称,16S rRNA 基因内部存在种内异质性,并且认为这会影响原核生物多样性的估计。在本研究中,分析了 2013 个细菌和古菌的完全测序基因组,发现 952 个基因组(585 个物种)存在种内异质性,检测到的分歧中有 87.5%低于 1%。特别是一些极端微生物(嗜热菌和嗜盐菌)被发现具有高度分化的 16S rRNA 基因。使用通常作为焦磷酸测序目标选择的全长和部分 16S rRNA 基因,在不同水平上评估 16S rRNA 基因种内异质性引起的高估。结果表明,在独特水平上,全长 16S rRNA 基因可能会产生高达 123.7%的高估,而在 3%的水平上,V6 区可能会引入 12.9%的高估。进一步分析表明,种内异质性倾向于集中在特定位置,细菌的 V1 和 V6 区受到的种内异质性最大,而 V4 和 V5 区受到的种内异质性最小。这是关于原核生物基因组中 16S rRNA 基因多样性的最新综述。它不仅提供了关于由于种内异质性,应用基于 16S rRNA 基因的方法可能会引入多少高估的一般性指导,而且还建议对于细菌,使用针对 V4 和 V5 区的引物可以最小化这种高估。