Magliano Joseph P, Millis Keith K, Levinstein Irwin
Northern Illinois University.
Metacogn Learn. 2011 Aug;6(2):131-154. doi: 10.1007/s11409-010-9064-2.
Comprehension emerges as the results of inference and strategic processes that support the construction of a coherent mental model for a text. However, the vast majority of comprehension skills tests adopt a format that does not afford an assessment of these processes as they operate during reading. This study assessed the viability of the Reading Strategy Assessment Tool (RSAT), which is an automated computer-based reading assessment designed to measure readers' comprehension and spontaneous use of reading strategies while reading texts. In the tool, readers comprehend passages one sentence at a time, and are asked either an indirect ("What are your thoughts regarding your understanding of the sentence in the context of the passage?") or direct (e.g., why X?) question after reading each pre-selected target sentence. The answers to the indirect questions are analyzed on the extent that they contain words associated with comprehension processes. The answers to direct questions are coded for the number of content words in common with an ideal answer, which is intended to be an assessment of emerging comprehension. In the study, the RSAT approach was shown to predict measures of comprehension comparable to standardized tests. The RSAT variables were also shown to correlate with human ratings. The results of this study constitute a "proof of concept" and demonstrate that it is possible to develop a comprehension skills assessment tool that assesses both comprehension and comprehension strategies.
理解是推理和策略过程的结果,这些过程支持为文本构建连贯的心理模型。然而,绝大多数理解技能测试采用的形式无法在阅读过程中对这些过程进行评估。本研究评估了阅读策略评估工具(RSAT)的可行性,该工具是一种基于计算机的自动化阅读评估,旨在测量读者在阅读文本时的理解能力和对阅读策略的自发运用。在该工具中,读者一次理解一个句子,并在读完每个预先选定的目标句子后被问到一个间接问题(“你对该句子在文章语境中的理解有什么想法?”)或直接问题(例如,为什么是X?)。间接问题的答案根据其包含与理解过程相关词汇的程度进行分析。直接问题的答案根据与理想答案共有的内容词数量进行编码,这旨在评估正在形成的理解。在该研究中,RSAT方法被证明能够预测与标准化测试相当的理解测量结果。RSAT变量也被证明与人工评分相关。本研究结果构成了一个“概念验证”,表明有可能开发一种既能评估理解能力又能评估理解策略的理解技能评估工具。