Institute of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jagiellonian University Collegium Medicum, Kraków, Poland.
Kardiol Pol. 2013;71(7):702-11. doi: 10.5603/KP.2013.0157.
Well designed cardiovascular disease (CVD) prevention programmes appear to be generally applicable and effective in reducing exposure to risk factors and the incidence of disease. However, introducing them broadly into clinical practice would have a significant impact on the healthcare budget, and requires careful consideration.
The purpose of this health economic analysis was to assess the potential cost-effectiveness of the model nurse-led, comprehensive CVD primary prevention programme which was prepared and introduced in the EUROACTION project, in high-risk patients in Poland.
A Markov model was developed to assess the long-term costs of preventive intervention. The health states modelled were: event-free (all patients at the beginning of observation), stable angina first year, acute myocardial infarction, stable angina subsequent year, myocardial infarction subsequent year, CVD death, and other causes of death. Health benefits from the reduction in risk factors were estimated based on Framingham risk function assuming the probability of defined health states according to British registers. The time horizon of the analysis was ten years, and one Markov cycle length was one year. The analysis was prepared from the healthcare payer's perspective. A willingness to pay threshold of three gross domestic product (GDP) per capita / quality-adjusted life years (QALY) was used. Univariate sensitivity analysis was conducted. Results were presented as an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) expressed as an incremental cost per QALY.
In Poland, EUROACTION intervention resulted mainly in reductions in the prevalence of smoking (by 14%) and high blood pressure (by 7%). Intervention on other risk factors, including blood lipids, was found to be less effective. Estimated ICERs were 19,524 PLN for men and 82,262 PLN for women. The programme was even more cost-effective in smokers i.e. estimated ICERs were 12,377 PLN in men and 53,471 PLN in women. The results were most sensitive to variations in health states utilities and cost value range as well as the duration of treatment effect.
The model nurse-led, comprehensive CVD primary prevention programme developed in the EUROACTION project appears to be potentially highly cost-effective for high-risk male patients in Poland (below 1 GDP per capita per QALY). For women, the cost-effectiveness was less but still below the acceptable threshold (below three GDP per capita per QALY), although the sensitivity analysis showed that results were a subject of some uncertainty.
精心设计的心血管疾病(CVD)预防计划似乎在降低风险因素暴露和疾病发病率方面具有普遍适用性和有效性。然而,将它们广泛引入临床实践将对医疗保健预算产生重大影响,因此需要仔细考虑。
本项健康经济学分析旨在评估 EUROACTION 项目中准备和实施的以护士为主导的综合 CVD 一级预防计划在波兰高危患者中的潜在成本效益。
建立了一个 Markov 模型来评估预防性干预的长期成本。所建模的健康状态为:无事件(所有患者在观察开始时)、稳定型心绞痛第一年、急性心肌梗死、稳定型心绞痛次年、心肌梗死次年、CVD 死亡和其他死因。根据英国登记册,基于 Framingham 风险函数,估计了风险因素降低带来的健康益处,假设了特定健康状态的概率。分析的时间范围为十年,一个 Markov 周期长度为一年。分析是从医疗保健支付者的角度准备的。使用了人均三个国内生产总值(GDP)/质量调整生命年(QALY)的意愿支付阈值。进行了单变量敏感性分析。结果以增量成本效益比(ICER)表示,每 QALY 的增量成本表示。
在波兰,EUROACTION 干预主要导致吸烟(减少 14%)和高血压(减少 7%)的流行率降低。干预其他风险因素,包括血脂,效果较差。男性的估计 ICER 为 19524 波兰兹罗提,女性为 82262 波兰兹罗提。对于吸烟者,该计划的成本效益甚至更高,男性的估计 ICER 为 12377 波兰兹罗提,女性为 53471 波兰兹罗提。结果对健康状态效用和成本值范围以及治疗效果持续时间的变化最为敏感。
EUROACTION 项目中开发的以护士为主导的综合 CVD 一级预防计划似乎对波兰高危男性患者具有潜在的高度成本效益(低于每 QALY 人均 1 GDP)。对于女性,成本效益较低,但仍低于可接受阈值(低于每 QALY 人均 3 GDP),尽管敏感性分析表明结果存在一定的不确定性。