Ríos Luis, Martínez Berta, García-Rubio Almudena, Herrasti Lourdes, Etxeberria Francisco
Unit of Physical Anthropology, Department of Biology, Faculty of Sciences, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, 28049, Spain,
Int J Legal Med. 2014 Sep;128(5):889-95. doi: 10.1007/s00414-013-0896-6. Epub 2013 Aug 6.
The presence of autopsy marks in human skeletal remains indicates a medicolegal procedure related to ascertaining the cause and manner of death. We present here four cases where signs of autopsy were observed in the remains recovered from mass graves and cemeteries of prisoners from the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), victims of extrajudicial executions, and of death in prison, respectively. With respect to the former, historical evidence indicate that during the first weeks after the coup, official removal of cadavers and autopsy procedures were carried out to the first victims of extrajudicial killings, whose corpses were found abandoned in the road. Once the civil war was established and systematic extrajudicial killings were systematic, official military orders were issued to stop standard forensic proceedings. Therefore, autopsy marks observed in the remains exhumed from mass graves located in cemeteries may be indicative of an earlier chronology of the killings, and this information proved to be relevant for the identification process in one of the cases presented. In a cemetery of political prisoners, autopsy signs were also observed in two skeletal remains and in the official records of two prisoners, a corroboration of information also relevant for the identification process. These findings indicate that autopsy marks can be found in the remains of victims of human rights violations exhumed from cemeteries. Skeletal and archival information could be useful for the identification process in other cases of large-scale violence, where the first victims of extrajudicial executions were buried unidentified in cemeteries after autopsy procedures.
人类骨骼遗骸上的尸检痕迹表明存在与确定死因和死亡方式相关的法医学程序。我们在此呈现四个案例,分别在从西班牙内战(1936 - 1939年)时期的乱葬岗和囚犯墓地中发掘出的遗骸上观察到了尸检迹象,这些遗骸的主人分别是法外处决的受害者和狱中死亡者。关于前者,历史证据表明,在政变后的头几周,官方对法外处决的首批受害者尸体进行了移走和尸检程序,这些受害者的尸体被发现遗弃在路上。一旦内战确立且法外处决系统化后,官方军事命令下达停止标准的法医程序。因此,在从墓地乱葬岗发掘出的遗骸上观察到的尸检痕迹可能表明杀戮时间更早,而这一信息在其中一个案例的身份鉴定过程中被证明是相关的。在一个政治犯墓地中,在两具骨骼遗骸以及两名囚犯的官方记录中也观察到了尸检迹象,这一信息佐证同样与身份鉴定过程相关。这些发现表明,在从墓地发掘出的侵犯人权受害者遗骸上能够发现尸检痕迹。骨骼和档案信息可能对其他大规模暴力案件的身份鉴定过程有用,在这些案件中,法外处决的首批受害者在经过尸检程序后身份不明地被埋葬在墓地中。