Kanner A M, Morris H H, Lüders H, Dinner D S, Wyllie E, Medendorp S V, Rowan A J
Section of Epilepsy and Clinical Neurophysiology, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, OH.
Neurology. 1990 Sep;40(9):1404-7. doi: 10.1212/wnl.40.9.1404.
Supplementary motor seizures (SMS) are among the group of frontal lobe seizures that may often be misdiagnosed as pseudoseizures (PS). We designed this study to determine the value of clinical phenomena in distinguishing between the two. In a series of patients with SMS, we identified those with symptoms mimicking PS and compared the clinical phenomena with those of clinically similar PS. We found that SMS are short in duration, stereotypic, tend to occur in sleep, and often present with a tonic contraction of the upper extremities in abduction. This sign was specific for SMS, particularly when occurring at the onset. Conversely, PS are long in duration, nonstereotypic, and occur in the awake state. We conclude that clinical phenomena may be useful in distinguishing PS from SMS, although the final diagnosis must be documented by neurophysiologic means.
辅助运动区癫痫发作(SMS)属于额叶癫痫发作类型,常被误诊为假性癫痫发作(PS)。我们开展这项研究以确定临床现象在鉴别这两者时的价值。在一系列SMS患者中,我们识别出有类似PS症状的患者,并将其临床现象与临床症状相似的PS患者进行比较。我们发现,SMS发作持续时间短、刻板,倾向于在睡眠中发作,且常表现为上肢外展时的强直收缩。这一征象对SMS具有特异性,尤其是在发作起始时出现。相反,PS发作持续时间长、无刻板性,且在清醒状态下发作。我们得出结论,临床现象可能有助于将PS与SMS区分开来,尽管最终诊断必须通过神经生理学手段来证实。