Graduate Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Anat Sci Educ. 2014 Mar-Apr;7(2):135-43. doi: 10.1002/ase.1393. Epub 2013 Aug 6.
To address the need for more clinical anatomy training in residency education, many postgraduate programs have implemented structured anatomy courses into their curriculum. Consensus often does not exist on specific content and level of detail of the content that should be included in such curricula. This article describes the use of the Delphi method to identify clinically relevant content to incorporate in a musculoskeletal anatomy curriculum for Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (PM&R) residents. A two round modified Delphi involving PM&R experts was used to establish the curricular content. The anatomical structures and clinical conditions presented to the expert group were compiled using multiple sources: clinical musculoskeletal anatomy cases from the PM&R residency program at the University of Toronto; consultation with PM&R experts; and textbooks. In each round, experts rated the importance of each curricular item to PM&R residency education using a five-point Likert scale. Internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha) was used to determine consensus at the end of each round and agreement scores were used as an outcome measure to determine the content to include in the curriculum. The overall internal consistency in both rounds was 0.99. A total of 37 physiatrists from across Canada participated and the overall response rate over two rounds was 97%. The initial curricular list consisted of 361 items. After the second iteration, the list was reduced by 44%. By using a national consensus method we were able to objectively determine the relevant anatomical structures and clinical musculoskeletal conditions important in daily PM&R practice.
为满足住院医师教育中对更多临床解剖学培训的需求,许多研究生课程已将结构化解剖学课程纳入课程体系。然而,对于这些课程应包含的具体内容和详细程度,往往没有达成共识。本文描述了使用 Delphi 方法来确定应纳入物理医学与康复(PM&R)住院医师肌肉骨骼解剖课程中的临床相关内容。采用两轮改良 Delphi 法,邀请 PM&R 专家参与,以确定课程内容。通过多种来源(多伦多大学 PM&R 住院医师项目中的临床肌肉骨骼解剖病例、与 PM&R 专家的咨询、教科书),向专家组编写了呈现的解剖结构和临床情况。在每一轮中,专家使用五点 Likert 量表对每个课程项目对 PM&R 住院医师教育的重要性进行评分。内部一致性(Cronbach's alpha)用于确定每轮结束时的共识,而一致性得分则作为衡量标准,用于确定课程中应包含的内容。两轮的整体内部一致性均为 0.99。共有来自加拿大各地的 37 名理疗医师参与,两轮的总体回复率为 97%。最初的课程列表包含 361 项内容。经过第二轮迭代,列表减少了 44%。通过使用全国共识方法,我们能够客观地确定在日常 PM&R 实践中重要的相关解剖结构和临床肌肉骨骼状况。