Correspondence to Brian Gygi:
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2013 Oct;56(5):1373-88. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2013/12-0283). Epub 2013 Aug 7.
Previously, Gygi and Shafiro (2011) found that when environmental sounds are semantically incongruent with the background scene (e.g., horse galloping in a restaurant), they can be identified more accurately by young normal-hearing listeners (YNH) than sounds congruent with the scene (e.g., horse galloping at a racetrack). This study investigated how age and high-frequency audibility affect this Incongruency Advantage (IA) effect.
In Experiments 1a and 1b, elderly listeners ( N = 18 for 1a; N = 10 for 1b) with age-appropriate hearing (EAH) were tested on target sounds and auditory scenes in 5 sound-to-scene ratios (So/Sc) between -3 and -18 dB. Experiment 2 tested 11 YNH on the same sound-scene pairings lowpass-filtered at 4 kHz (YNH-4k).
The EAH and YNH-4k groups exhibited an almost identical pattern of significant IA effects, but both were at approximately 3.9 dB higher So/Sc than the previously tested YNH listeners. However, the psychometric functions revealed a shallower slope for EAH listeners compared with YNH listeners for the congruent stimuli only, suggesting a greater difficulty for the EAH listeners in attending to sounds expected to occur in a scene.
These findings indicate that semantic relationships between environmental sounds in soundscapes are mediated by both audibility and cognitive factors and suggest a method for dissociating these factors.
此前,Gygi 和 Shafiro(2011 年)发现,当环境声音与背景场景在语义上不一致时(例如,餐厅里的马奔腾声),年轻正常听力听众(YNH)比与场景一致的声音(例如,赛马场上的马奔腾声)更能准确地识别它们。本研究调查了年龄和高频可听度如何影响这种不和谐优势(IA)效应。
在实验 1a 和 1b 中,具有年龄相关听力(EAH)的老年听众(1a 组为 18 人;1b 组为 10 人)对 5 个声音与场景比(So/Sc)在-3 到-18dB 之间的目标声音和听觉场景进行了测试。实验 2 测试了 11 名 YNH 在相同的声音-场景配对上进行 4kHz 低通滤波(YNH-4k)。
EAH 和 YNH-4k 组表现出几乎相同的显著 IA 效应模式,但这两个组的 So/Sc 比之前测试的 YNH 听众高约 3.9dB。然而,心理物理函数显示,对于一致的刺激,EAH 听众的斜率比 YNH 听众更浅,这表明 EAH 听众在关注预计出现在场景中的声音方面存在更大的困难。
这些发现表明,声音景观中环境声音之间的语义关系受到可听度和认知因素的共同影响,并提出了一种分离这些因素的方法。