Correspondence to Estella P.-M. Ma:
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2013 Oct;56(5):1409-15. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2013/11-0242). Epub 2013 Aug 7.
To investigate the attitudes of school teachers toward children with voice problems in a Chinese population.
Three groups of listeners participated in this study: primary school teachers, speech-language pathology students, and general university students. The participants were required to make attitude judgments on 12 voice samples using a semantic differential scale with 22 bipolar adjective pairs. The voice samples were collected from 6 children with healthy voices and 6 children with dysphonia. The 22 bipolar adjective pairs were intended to cover nonspeech characteristics about the child's personality, social characteristics, and physical appearance.
The mean attitude ratings received by children with dysphonic voice were significantly lower (i.e., less favorable) than those received by children with healthy voices in all of the 22 adjective pairs (all ps < .002). The attitude ratings made by the 3 groups of listeners were not significantly different from one another ( ps > .05).
To our knowledge, this is the first study in which the authors examine listeners' perception toward children with voice problems in the Chinese population. The results suggest that voice problems in children warrant attention, and their effects on the child should not be underestimated. The findings also highlight the importance of early identification and intervention for children with voice problems.
调查中国人群中学校教师对有嗓音问题儿童的态度。
本研究有三组听众参与:小学教师、言语病理学生和普通大学生。要求参与者使用包含 22 对极性形容词的语义差异量表对 12 个嗓音样本进行态度判断。嗓音样本取自 6 名嗓音正常的儿童和 6 名患有发声障碍的儿童。这 22 对极性形容词旨在涵盖有关儿童个性、社会特征和外貌的非言语特征。
患有发声障碍的儿童的平均态度评分明显低于(即不那么有利)所有 22 对形容词(均 p<.002)的健康儿童。三组听众的态度评分彼此之间没有显著差异(p>.05)。
据作者所知,这是首次研究中国人群中听众对有嗓音问题儿童的感知。结果表明,儿童的嗓音问题值得关注,不应低估其对儿童的影响。研究结果还强调了早期识别和干预儿童嗓音问题的重要性。