Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Northwestern University, 2240 Campus Drive, Evanston, Illinois 60208, USA.
J Acoust Soc Am. 2013 Aug;134(2):1172-82. doi: 10.1121/1.4812258.
While it is commonly held that the capacity to learn is greatest in the young, there have been few direct comparisons of the response to training across age groups. Here, adolescents (11-17 years, n = 20) and adults (≥18 years, n = 11) practiced detecting a backward-masked tone for ∼1 h/day for 10 days. Nearly every adult, but only half of the adolescents improved across sessions, and the adolescents who learned did so more slowly than adults. Nevertheless, the adolescent and adult learners showed the same generalization pattern, improving on untrained backward- but not forward- or simultaneous-masking conditions. Another subset of adolescents (n = 6) actually got worse on the trained condition. This worsening, unlike learning, generalized to an untrained forward-masking, but not backward-masking condition. Within sessions, both age groups got worse, but the worsening was greater for adolescents. These maturational changes in the response to training largely followed those previously reported for temporal-interval discrimination. Overall, the results suggest that late-maturing processes affect the response to perceptual training and that some of these processes may be shared between tasks. Further, the different developmental rates for learning and generalization, and different generalization patterns for learning and worsening imply that learning, generalization, and worsening may have different origins.
虽然人们普遍认为学习能力在年轻时最强,但很少有直接比较不同年龄组对训练反应的研究。在这里,青少年(11-17 岁,n=20)和成年人(≥18 岁,n=11)每天练习检测大约 1 小时的掩蔽后音调,持续 10 天。几乎每个成年人都有所进步,但只有一半的青少年有进步,而且青少年的学习速度比成年人慢。然而,青少年和成年学习者表现出相同的泛化模式,在未训练的掩蔽后但不是掩蔽前或同时掩蔽条件下都有所提高。另一组青少年(n=6)实际上在训练条件下表现更差。这种恶化与学习不同,它泛化到未训练的掩蔽前条件,但不能泛化到掩蔽后条件。在每个训练阶段,两个年龄组的表现都有所下降,但青少年的下降幅度更大。这些对训练反应的成熟变化在很大程度上与之前报告的时间间隔辨别任务的变化相似。总的来说,这些结果表明,后期成熟过程会影响对感知训练的反应,并且这些过程中的一些可能在任务之间共享。此外,学习和泛化的不同发展速度以及学习和恶化的不同泛化模式表明,学习、泛化和恶化可能有不同的起源。