Alhilali L, Seo S-h, Branstetter B F, Fakhran S
From the Departments of Radiology (L.A., S.-h.S., B.F.B., S.F.).
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2014 Feb;35(2):386-9. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A3683. Epub 2013 Aug 8.
Globus sensation is common and difficult to treat. The purpose of our study was to compare the diagnostic and therapeutic efficacy of barium esophagram and neck CT in patients with isolated globus sensation, to determine which of these modalities should be preferred in the evaluation of this condition.
We retrospectively identified patients presenting with isolated globus sensation from January 1, 2005, to December 31, 2012, who underwent neck CT or barium esophagram. We calculated the proportion of patients with abnormal findings, tabulated the nature of the abnormality, and reviewed the medical records to determine whether imaging changed management.
One hundred forty-eight neck CTs and 104 barium esophagrams were included. Five (3.4%) patients with neck CTs and 4 (3.9%) with barium esophagrams demonstrated significant findings related to the history of globus sensation. Of these, 1 (0.7%) neck CT and 1 (1.0%) barium esophagram resulted in a change in clinical management.
Imaging evaluation of the patient with uncomplicated globus sensation is unlikely to identify clinically significant imaging findings and is very unlikely to result in a change in clinical management, with a combined therapeutic efficacy of 0.8%. Thus, the routine use of imaging in the evaluation of patients with globus sensation cannot be recommended.
咽异感症很常见且难以治疗。我们研究的目的是比较钡剂食管造影和颈部CT对孤立性咽异感症患者的诊断及治疗效果,以确定在评估这种情况时哪种检查方式更值得首选。
我们回顾性纳入了2005年1月1日至2012年12月31日期间因孤立性咽异感症接受颈部CT或钡剂食管造影检查的患者。我们计算了检查结果异常的患者比例,列出异常的性质,并查阅病历以确定影像学检查是否改变了治疗方案。
共纳入148例颈部CT检查和104例钡剂食管造影检查。5例(3.4%)颈部CT检查患者和4例(3.9%)钡剂食管造影检查患者有与咽异感症病史相关的显著检查结果。其中,1例(0.7%)颈部CT检查和1例(1.0%)钡剂食管造影检查导致了临床治疗方案的改变。
对单纯性咽异感症患者进行影像学评估不太可能发现具有临床意义的影像学表现,也极不可能导致临床治疗方案的改变,综合治疗有效率为0.8%。因此,不建议对咽异感症患者常规进行影像学检查。