Dipartimento di Discipline Chirurgiche, Oncologiche e Stomatologiche (Plesso di Odontostomatologia), Università di Palermo, Via del Vespro 129, 90127 Palermo, Italy.
J Dent Educ. 2013 Aug;77(8):1072-8.
The aim of this study was to assess the level of tobacco dependence education offered by Italian dental hygiene programs. A fifty-question survey was mailed to the thirty-one active public and private dental hygiene programs in Italy during the 2008-09 academic year. The survey assessed faculty confidence in teaching tobacco treatment, which courses contained tobacco dependence content, the number of minutes spent on specific content areas, and the level of clinical competence that dental hygiene graduates should be able to demonstrate. Surveys were returned by sixteen programs for a response rate of 52 percent. Respondents indicated tobacco dependence education was included in clinic or clinic seminar (56 percent), periodontics (44 percent), oral pathology (31 percent), and prevention (19 percent). All programs reported including the effects of tobacco on general and oral diseases in courses. However, more in-depth topics received less curriculum time; these included tobacco treatment strategies (63 percent) and discussion of cessation medications (31 percent). Interestingly, 62 percent of the respondents indicated they expected dental hygiene graduates to demonstrate a tobacco treatment competency level of a moderate intervention or higher (counseling, discussion of medications, follow-up) rather than a brief intervention in which patients are advised to quit then referred to a quitline. The results of this study indicated that Italian dental hygiene students are not currently receiving adequate instruction in tobacco treatment techniques nor are they being adequately assessed. This unique overview of Italian dental hygiene tobacco dependence education provides a basis for further discussion towards a national competency-based curriculum.
本研究旨在评估意大利牙科保健项目提供的烟草依赖教育水平。在 2008-09 学年,向意大利 31 个公立和私立牙科保健项目的在职教员邮寄了一份包含 50 个问题的调查问卷。该调查评估了教员在教授烟草治疗方面的信心,包含烟草依赖内容的课程,特定内容领域所花费的时间,以及牙科保健专业毕业生应具备的临床能力水平。16 个项目对调查做出了回应,回应率为 52%。受访者表示,烟草依赖教育包含在诊所或诊所研讨会(56%)、牙周病学(44%)、口腔病理学(31%)和预防(19%)课程中。所有项目都报告在课程中包含了烟草对一般疾病和口腔疾病的影响。然而,更深入的主题课程时间较少,包括烟草治疗策略(63%)和停止用药讨论(31%)。有趣的是,62%的受访者表示,他们期望牙科保健专业毕业生能够展示出中等干预或更高水平(咨询、药物讨论、随访)的烟草治疗能力,而不是建议患者戒烟并转介戒烟热线的简短干预。这项研究的结果表明,意大利的牙科保健专业学生目前没有接受足够的烟草治疗技术指导,也没有接受足够的评估。对意大利牙科保健烟草依赖教育的这一独特概述为进一步讨论基于国家能力的课程提供了基础。