a Department of Psychology , University of Notre Dame , Notre Dame , Indiana , USA.
Child Neuropsychol. 2014;20(5):539-56. doi: 10.1080/09297049.2013.826185. Epub 2013 Aug 12.
There has been great interest in using working memory (WM) training regimens as an alternative treatment for ADHD, but it has recently been concluded that existing training regimens may not be optimally designed because they target the primary memory component but not the secondary component of WM capacity. This conclusion requires the ability to accurately measure changes in primary and secondary memory abilities over time. The immediate free recall task has been used in previous studies to measure these changes; however, one concern with these tasks is that the recall order required on training exercises may influence the recall strategy used during free recall, which may in turn influence the relative number of items recalled from primary and secondary memory. To address this issue, previous training studies have explicitly controlled recall strategy before and after training. However, the necessity of controlling for recall strategies has not been explicitly tested. The present study investigated the effects of forward-serial-order training on free recall performance under conditions in which recall strategy was not controlled using a sample of adolescents with ADHD. Unlike when recall order was controlled, the main findings showed selective improvement of the secondary memory component (as opposed to the primary memory component) when recall order was uncontrolled. This finding advances our understanding of WM training by highlighting the importance of controlling for recall strategies when free recall tasks are used to measure changes in the primary and secondary components of WM across time.
人们对使用工作记忆(WM)训练方案作为 ADHD 的替代治疗方法非常感兴趣,但最近的结论认为,现有的训练方案可能设计得不够理想,因为它们针对的是 WM 能力的主要记忆成分,而不是次要成分。这一结论需要能够准确测量主要和次要记忆能力随时间的变化。即时自由回忆任务在以前的研究中被用来衡量这些变化;然而,这些任务的一个问题是,训练练习中所需的回忆顺序可能会影响自由回忆中使用的回忆策略,而这反过来又可能影响从主要和次要记忆中回忆的项目的相对数量。为了解决这个问题,以前的训练研究在训练前后都明确控制了回忆策略。然而,控制回忆策略的必要性尚未得到明确检验。本研究在未控制回忆策略的情况下,使用 ADHD 青少年样本,调查了正向顺序训练对自由回忆表现的影响。与控制回忆顺序时不同,当不控制回忆顺序时,主要发现显示了次要记忆成分(而不是主要记忆成分)的选择性改善。这一发现通过强调在使用自由回忆任务来衡量 WM 主要和次要成分随时间的变化时控制回忆策略的重要性,推进了我们对 WM 训练的理解。